Breakdown of In foro puella non vult a turba premi, sed a matre duci.
Questions & Answers about In foro puella non vult a turba premi, sed a matre duci.
Why is puella nominative, even though she is the one being pressed and led?
Because puella is the subject of vult: the girl does not want...
With verbs like volo (I want), Latin often uses a subject + infinitive construction:
- puella vult duci = the girl wants to be led
- literally, the girl wants to be led
So even though puella is the receiver of the actions in premi and duci, she is still grammatically the subject of the main verb vult.
Why are premi and duci translated as to be pressed and to be led?
Because they are present passive infinitives.
- premi comes from premo, premere = press, crush
- duci comes from duco, ducere = lead
Their passive infinitive forms mean:
- premi = to be pressed / crushed
- duci = to be led
So the sentence means that the girl does not want to be pressed by the crowd, but to be led by her mother.
Why is Latin using infinitives after vult?
Because volo commonly takes an infinitive to express what someone wants.
Examples:
- vult ire = she wants to go
- vult manere = she wants to stay
- vult duci = she wants to be led
In this sentence:
- non vult ... premi ... duci means
- she does not want to be pressed ... but to be led
This is very normal Latin structure.
Why is there only one non? Does it apply to both infinitives?
Yes. The non goes with vult, and that negation covers the whole contrast:
- non vult a turba premi, sed a matre duci
This means:
- she does not want to be pressed by the crowd, but rather to be led by her mother
So the idea is not:
- she does not want X, and she does want Y stated with two separate verbs,
but rather:
- she does not want X, but instead wants Y
Latin often lets sed handle that contrast without repeating vult.
Why are a turba and a matre introduced by a?
Because with a passive verb, Latin often uses a/ab + ablative to show the personal agent: the person or group doing the action.
So:
- a turba premi = to be pressed by the crowd
- a matre duci = to be led by [her] mother
This is the regular way to express by someone with the passive.
Why are turba and matre in the ablative?
They are ablative because they follow a, which takes the ablative case here.
Their dictionary forms are:
- turba, turbae = crowd
- mater, matris = mother
In the ablative singular, they become:
- turba
- matre
So:
- a turba = by the crowd
- a matre = by the mother
What does in foro mean grammatically, and why is foro ablative?
In foro means in the forum / marketplace.
The preposition in takes the ablative when it means in or on in a location:
- in foro = in the forum
- in urbe = in the city
- in casa = in the house
If in meant motion into something, it would usually take the accusative instead.
So here foro is ablative because it shows place where, not movement.
What is the function of sed here?
Sed means but.
It sets up a contrast:
- non vult a turba premi
- sed a matre duci
That is:
- she does not want to be pressed by the crowd
- but [she wants] to be led by her mother
So sed contrasts the two infinitive phrases very neatly: not this, but that.
Why doesn’t Latin repeat vult before a matre duci?
Because Latin often leaves out a word when it is easily understood from the context.
So this:
- puella non vult a turba premi, sed a matre duci
effectively means:
- puella non vult a turba premi, sed [vult] a matre duci
English can do something similar:
- She does not want to be pushed, but to be led.
You do not have to repeat wants in English either.
Could a turba mean from the crowd instead of by the crowd?
In some contexts, a/ab can mean from. But here, because it is used with passive infinitives (premi, duci), the natural meaning is by.
So:
- a turba premi is understood as to be pressed by the crowd not
- to be pressed from the crowd
The passive construction strongly points to agent, not separation.
How should I understand the overall structure of the sentence?
A helpful breakdown is:
- In foro = in the forum
- puella = the girl
- non vult = does not want
- a turba premi = to be pressed by the crowd
- sed a matre duci = but to be led by her mother
So the core pattern is:
- subject + non vult + infinitive, sed + infinitive
That makes the sentence a good example of:
- a main verb of wanting
- followed by passive infinitives
- with a contrast introduced by sed
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from In foro puella non vult a turba premi, sed a matre duci to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions