Breakdown of densya no naka de ha tuution ga denai you ni, sumaho wo muon ni site iru.
Questions & Answers about densya no naka de ha tuution ga denai you ni, sumaho wo muon ni site iru.
Why is it 電車の中で instead of just 電車で?
電車で often means by train as a means of transportation.
- 学校へ電車で行く = I go to school by train
But 電車の中で specifically means inside the train.
In this sentence, the speaker is talking about what they do while they are physically on the train, so 電車の中で is clearer.
What does では mean here?
Why is the place marked with で and not に?
A common rule of thumb is:
- に = location of existence, destination, specific point
- で = location/setting where an action happens
Here, the sentence is about the action/state of keeping the phone silent in that setting, so で is natural.
Compare:
- 電車の中にいる = to be in the train
- 電車の中でスマホを無音にしている = to keep the phone silent in the train
Why is it 通知音が出ない instead of 通知音を出さない?
This is about intransitive vs. transitive wording.
- 出る = to come out, be emitted, be produced
- 出す = to put out, produce
So:
- 通知音が出ない = the notification sound does not come out
- 通知音を出さない = not produce the notification sound
Both can work, but they focus a little differently:
- 通知音が出ないように focuses on the result
- 通知音を出さないように focuses more on the person’s action
Because 出ない is intransitive, 通知音 takes が.
Why does Japanese use 出る for a sound?
Because in Japanese, sounds often come out.
Very common expressions are:
- 音が出る = sound comes out / sound is produced
- 声が出る = voice comes out
- 涙が出る = tears come out
So 通知音が出る is a very natural Japanese way to say that a notification sound is emitted.
What does ように mean here?
Here, ~ないように means so that ... not or in order to prevent ....
So:
- 通知音が出ないように = so that notification sounds won’t come out
This pattern is very common when talking about trying to achieve or avoid a certain result.
Examples:
- 忘れないようにメモする = I make a note so that I won’t forget
- 風邪をひかないように気をつける = I’m careful so that I won’t catch a cold
Could ために be used instead of ように?
Usually ように is the more natural choice here.
A rough difference is:
- ために often expresses a more direct, intentional purpose
- ように often expresses aiming for a result, especially with things that are not fully under direct control or are phrased as a state/result
Since 通知音が出ない is a result/state, ように fits very well.
So 通知音が出ないために is not impossible in every context, but 通知音が出ないように sounds more natural here.
What does 無音にする mean, and why is there a に?
無音 means no sound / silent.
The pattern A にする means to make something A or to set something to A.
So:
- スマホを無音にする = to set the smartphone to silent
The particle に marks the state the phone is being changed into.
Similar patterns:
- 部屋をきれいにする = make the room clean
- 音を小さくする = make the sound quieter
Why is it している instead of する?
~ている here shows a continuing state.
After you set your phone to silent, it stays in that state. So:
- 無音にする = set it to silent
- 無音にしている = keep it on silent / have it on silent
So this sentence does not mean I am in the middle of silencing it right now.
It means I keep my phone silent in that situation.
It can also suggest a habit:
- When I’m on the train, I keep my phone on silent.
Who is the subject of the sentence? Where is I?
It is omitted.
Japanese very often leaves out the subject when it is obvious from context. In this sentence, the understood subject is usually:
- I
- or whatever person the conversation is already about
So even though 私 does not appear, the sentence naturally means something like I keep my phone on silent...
Is 無音 the most natural word here? Could I say something else?
Yes, you could say something else.
- スマホ is a very common casual word for smartphone
- スマートフォン is the full form
For the silent setting, many people would also say:
- マナーモードにしている
- サイレントモードにしている
These may sound more like the actual phone setting name.
無音にしている is understandable and natural enough, but it sounds a bit more literally like making it silent / muting it.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from densya no naka de ha tuution ga denai you ni, sumaho wo muon ni site iru to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions