gassyou no ato de, minna ga ookina koe de 「yokatta」 to iimasita.

Questions & Answers about gassyou no ato de, minna ga ookina koe de 「yokatta」 to iimasita.

What does 合唱のあとで mean grammatically, and why is used there?

あと is a noun meaning after or the time after.

When あと follows another noun, you usually connect them with :

  • 合唱 = chorus / choral singing
  • 合唱のあと = after the chorus

Then turns the whole thing into a time expression meaning after the chorus or after the singing.

So:

  • 合唱のあとで、… = After the chorus, ...

This is a very common pattern:

  • 授業のあとで = after class
  • 食事のあとで = after the meal

Could this sentence use あと without ?

Yes. 合唱のあと、 would also be natural.

The difference is small:

  • 合唱のあと、 = after the chorus
  • 合唱のあとで、 = after the chorus / afterward

In many sentences, both are fine. あとで often sounds a little more like a complete time phrase.

Also note that あとで can sometimes mean later, depending on context, but here it clearly means after the chorus.


Why is it みんなが instead of みんなは?

marks みんな as the subject of the action: the people who said something.

So:

  • みんなが言いました = everyone said it

Using here is a neutral, straightforward way to describe what happened.

If you used instead:

  • みんなは言いました

that would sound more like as for everyone, they said..., which can add a topic or contrast nuance.

So is very natural here because the sentence is simply reporting an event.


What does 大きな声で mean, and what is the doing?

大きな声で means in a loud voice.

Breakdown:

  • 大きな = big / loud
  • = voice
  • 大きな声 = a loud voice
  • 大きな声で = in a loud voice

The particle here marks the manner of the action: how something was done.

So:

  • 大きな声で言いました = said it in a loud voice

This is not a location marker here. It tells you the way the speaking happened.

Similar examples:

  • 小さい声で話す = speak in a quiet voice
  • 日本語で話す = speak in Japanese

Why is it 大きな and not 大きい?

Both 大きな声 and 大きい声 are possible.

A useful way to think about it is:

  • 大きい is the regular -い adjective
  • 大きな is a special form used only directly before nouns

So:

  • 大きい can appear at the end of a sentence: 声が大きい
  • 大きな cannot: you would not say 声が大きな

Before a noun, both are often natural:

  • 大きい声
  • 大きな声

In this sentence, 大きな声 sounds very normal and natural.


Why is the quoted word よかった in past tense?

Because it comes from いい / よい, whose past form is よかった.

  • いい = good
  • よかった = was good

But in real Japanese, よかった! is very often used as an exclamation, not just as a literal past-tense statement.

Depending on context, it can mean things like:

  • That was great!
  • It was good!
  • I’m glad!
  • That went well!

So even though it is grammatically past tense, it is a very natural reaction to something that has just happened.


What does the particle do after よかった?

is the quotation particle.

It marks the content of what was said:

  • 「よかった」と言いました = said “It was good!”

This pattern is extremely common:

  • A と言う = say A
  • A と思う = think A
  • A と聞いた = heard that A

So here, connects the quoted words よかった to the verb 言いました.


Why are 「 」 used around よかった?

「 」 are Japanese quotation marks. They work like English quotation marks.

So:

  • 「よかった」 = “That was great” / “It was good”

They show that these are the exact words people said.

Japanese can sometimes omit quotation marks if the sentence is still clear, but using 「 」 makes the direct quote very obvious.


Why is the final verb 言いました and not 言った?

言いました is the polite past form of 言う.

  • 言う = to say
  • 言った = said (plain form)
  • 言いました = said (polite form)

The whole sentence is written in polite style, so the final verb is polite too.

If the sentence were written in plain style, it would be:

  • 合唱のあとで、みんなが大きな声で「よかった」と言った。

Both are correct; the difference is politeness/style.


What is the basic structure of the whole sentence?

The sentence follows a very common Japanese order:

  • 合唱のあとで = time expression
  • みんなが = subject
  • 大きな声で = manner
  • 「よかった」と = quotation
  • 言いました = verb

So Japanese builds the sentence piece by piece and puts the main verb at the end.

A natural breakdown is:

  • After the chorus,
  • everyone
  • in a loud voice
  • “That was great!”
  • said.

That final-verb structure is one of the most important patterns in Japanese.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
How do verb conjugations work in Japanese?
Japanese verbs conjugate based on tense, politeness, and mood. For example, the polite present form adds ‑ます to the verb stem, while the past tense uses ‑ました. Unlike English, Japanese verbs don't change based on the subject — the same form works for "I", "you", and "they".

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Japanese

Master Japanese — from gassyou no ato de, minna ga ookina koe de 「yokatta」 to iimasita to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • AI tutor to answer your grammar questions