Breakdown of gassyou no ato de, minna ga ookina koe de 「yokatta」 to iimasita.
Questions & Answers about gassyou no ato de, minna ga ookina koe de 「yokatta」 to iimasita.
What does 合唱のあとで mean grammatically, and why is の used there?
あと is a noun meaning after or the time after.
When あと follows another noun, you usually connect them with の:
- 合唱 = chorus / choral singing
- 合唱のあと = after the chorus
Then で turns the whole thing into a time expression meaning after the chorus or after the singing.
So:
- 合唱のあとで、… = After the chorus, ...
This is a very common pattern:
- 授業のあとで = after class
- 食事のあとで = after the meal
Could this sentence use あと without で?
Yes. 合唱のあと、 would also be natural.
The difference is small:
- 合唱のあと、 = after the chorus
- 合唱のあとで、 = after the chorus / afterward
In many sentences, both are fine. あとで often sounds a little more like a complete time phrase.
Also note that あとで can sometimes mean later, depending on context, but here it clearly means after the chorus.
Why is it みんなが instead of みんなは?
が marks みんな as the subject of the action: the people who said something.
So:
- みんなが言いました = everyone said it
Using が here is a neutral, straightforward way to describe what happened.
If you used は instead:
- みんなは言いました
that would sound more like as for everyone, they said..., which can add a topic or contrast nuance.
So が is very natural here because the sentence is simply reporting an event.
What does 大きな声で mean, and what is the で doing?
大きな声で means in a loud voice.
Breakdown:
- 大きな = big / loud
- 声 = voice
- 大きな声 = a loud voice
- 大きな声で = in a loud voice
The particle で here marks the manner of the action: how something was done.
So:
- 大きな声で言いました = said it in a loud voice
This で is not a location marker here. It tells you the way the speaking happened.
Similar examples:
- 小さい声で話す = speak in a quiet voice
- 日本語で話す = speak in Japanese
Why is it 大きな and not 大きい?
Both 大きな声 and 大きい声 are possible.
A useful way to think about it is:
So:
- 大きい can appear at the end of a sentence: 声が大きい
- 大きな cannot: you would not say 声が大きな
Before a noun, both are often natural:
- 大きい声
- 大きな声
In this sentence, 大きな声 sounds very normal and natural.
Why is the quoted word よかった in past tense?
Because it comes from いい / よい, whose past form is よかった.
- いい = good
- よかった = was good
But in real Japanese, よかった! is very often used as an exclamation, not just as a literal past-tense statement.
Depending on context, it can mean things like:
- That was great!
- It was good!
- I’m glad!
- That went well!
So even though it is grammatically past tense, it is a very natural reaction to something that has just happened.
What does the particle と do after よかった?
と is the quotation particle.
It marks the content of what was said:
- 「よかった」と言いました = said “It was good!”
This pattern is extremely common:
- A と言う = say A
- A と思う = think A
- A と聞いた = heard that A
So here, と connects the quoted words よかった to the verb 言いました.
Why are 「 」 used around よかった?
「 」 are Japanese quotation marks. They work like English quotation marks.
So:
- 「よかった」 = “That was great” / “It was good”
They show that these are the exact words people said.
Japanese can sometimes omit quotation marks if the sentence is still clear, but using 「 」 makes the direct quote very obvious.
Why is the final verb 言いました and not 言った?
言いました is the polite past form of 言う.
- 言う = to say
- 言った = said (plain form)
- 言いました = said (polite form)
The whole sentence is written in polite style, so the final verb is polite too.
If the sentence were written in plain style, it would be:
- 合唱のあとで、みんなが大きな声で「よかった」と言った。
Both are correct; the difference is politeness/style.
What is the basic structure of the whole sentence?
The sentence follows a very common Japanese order:
- 合唱のあとで = time expression
- みんなが = subject
- 大きな声で = manner
- 「よかった」と = quotation
- 言いました = verb
So Japanese builds the sentence piece by piece and puts the main verb at the end.
A natural breakdown is:
- After the chorus,
- everyone
- in a loud voice
- “That was great!”
- said.
That final-verb structure is one of the most important patterns in Japanese.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from gassyou no ato de, minna ga ookina koe de 「yokatta」 to iimasita to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions