Breakdown of onazi kyoukasyo wo tukatte mo, hito ni yotte kangaekata ha tigaimasu.
Questions & Answers about onazi kyoukasyo wo tukatte mo, hito ni yotte kangaekata ha tigaimasu.
What does 使っても mean here, and why is も attached to the て-form?
使っても is the pattern Vて + も, which often means:
- even if ...
- even though ...
- although ...
So:
In this sentence, it connects to the next idea:
- 同じ教科書を使っても、...違います
- Even if they use the same textbook, ... things are different
The nuance is concessive: you might expect the same textbook to lead to the same result, but that is not necessarily true.
Why is it 同じ教科書 and not 同じの教科書 or something with な?
同じ is a special word. It can directly modify a noun:
- 同じ教科書 = the same textbook
- 同じ人 = the same person
- 同じ考え = the same idea
You do not use な here:
- natural: 同じ教科書
- unnatural: 同じな教科書
You also do not need の in this structure.
So 同じ behaves a little unusually compared with regular な-adjectives.
Why is there an を after 教科書?
Because 教科書 is the direct object of 使う.
- 教科書を使う = to use a textbook
Even though 使っても is part of a larger sentence, it still keeps its normal object marker:
- 同じ教科書を使っても = even if/though (someone) uses the same textbook
So the structure is still:
- object + を
- verb
What does 人によって mean here?
人によって means depending on the person or from person to person.
This is the pattern:
- Nによって = depending on N / according to N / varying by N
So:
- 人によって = depending on the person
- 国によって = depending on the country
- 場合によって = depending on the situation
In this sentence, it means that the difference comes from the individual person:
- 人によって考え方は違います
- Ways of thinking differ from person to person
How is によって different from にとって?
They are very different.
によって
Means:
- depending on
- by
- according to
- due to
Example in this sentence:
- 人によって違います
- It differs depending on the person
にとって
Means:
- for
- to
- from the viewpoint of
Example:
- 私にとって難しい
- It is difficult for me
So in this sentence, 人によって is correct because the meaning is variation by person, not from the perspective of a person.
What does 考え方 mean literally?
考え方 literally means way of thinking.
It is made from:
- 考え = the stem of 考える (to think)
- 方 = way/method of doing something
So this pattern often creates words meaning how to do something:
- 使い方 = way of using / how to use
- 読み方 = way of reading / how to read
- 考え方 = way of thinking
In this sentence, 考え方 refers to a person’s mindset, ideas, or approach.
Why is the sentence 考え方は違います and not 考え方が違います?
Both は and が are possible in many contexts, but they give slightly different nuances.
考え方は違います
This sounds like:
- As for ways of thinking, they differ
- It presents 考え方 as the topic
- It can also carry a slight contrastive feeling
考え方が違います
This would sound more like:
- The thing that differs is the way of thinking
- More direct focus on what is different
In this sentence, は works well because the speaker is making a general statement about people: even with the same textbook, their ways of thinking are different.
Who is the subject of 使っても? Why isn’t it stated?
The subject is omitted because Japanese often leaves it unstated when it is understood from context.
English usually needs something like:
- Even if people use the same textbook...
- Even if students use the same textbook...
But Japanese often does not say that explicitly if it is obvious or meant generally.
So here, the sentence is making a broad statement about people in general. The implied meaning is something like:
- Even if people use the same textbook, ways of thinking differ from person to person.
Why is 人 singular-looking if the meaning is about many people?
In Japanese, nouns usually do not change form for singular vs. plural the way English nouns do.
So:
- 人 can mean a person or people, depending on context
In 人によって, it does not mean just one specific person. It means:
- depending on the person
- from person to person
This is a very common Japanese way to express general variation among individuals.
Is 違います the same as different in English? How does 違う work grammatically?
Yes, here 違います means is different / are different, but grammatically 違う is a verb, not an adjective.
- 違う = to differ / to be different
Polite form:
- 違います
So:
- 考え方は違います
- Ways of thinking differ / are different
This is one reason the sentence does not need a separate word meaning are. The verb 違います already carries the idea.
Could 使っても here be translated as even if or even though? Which is better?
Both are possible, and the best choice depends on how natural you want the English to sound.
even if
Focuses more on the condition:
- Even if people use the same textbook, ...
even though
Focuses more on the fact:
- Even though people use the same textbook, ...
In Japanese, Vて + も can cover both kinds of meaning. In this sentence, the nuance is basically:
- using the same textbook does not guarantee the same way of thinking
So either translation is reasonable.
Why is there a comma after も?
The comma marks a pause between the first clause and the main clause:
- 同じ教科書を使っても、
- 人によって考え方は違います。
It helps separate:
- the concessive part: Even if/though they use the same textbook
- the main statement: ways of thinking differ from person to person
In Japanese writing, commas are often used more flexibly than in English, but here it makes the sentence easier to read.
Could this sentence be rephrased in a simpler way?
Yes. A simpler paraphrase would be:
- 同じ教科書を使っても、人それぞれ考え方が違います。
Here 人それぞれ means something like each person is different or each person has their own way.
Another possible paraphrase:
- 同じ教科書を使っても、考え方は人によって違います。
This keeps the same meaning but changes the word order slightly. Japanese allows that kind of flexibility more than English does.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from onazi kyoukasyo wo tukatte mo, hito ni yotte kangaekata ha tigaimasu to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions