Breakdown of Wohin hast du den Schnuller gelegt? Ich finde ihn weder im Kinderbett noch im Hochstuhl.
Questions & Answers about Wohin hast du den Schnuller gelegt? Ich finde ihn weder im Kinderbett noch im Hochstuhl.
Why does the sentence use wohin instead of wo?
Because wohin asks about direction or destination: to where?
- Wo = where? for a static location
- Wohin = where to? for movement toward a place
Here, the speaker is asking where someone put the pacifier, so the important idea is movement to a location:
- Wohin hast du den Schnuller gelegt? = Where did you put the pacifier?
If you were only asking where it is now, you would normally use wo:
- Wo ist der Schnuller? = Where is the pacifier?
Why is it hast du ... gelegt?
This is the Perfekt tense, which is very commonly used in spoken German to talk about the past.
The pattern is:
- haben
- past participle
So:
- hast = auxiliary verb from haben
- gelegt = past participle of legen
Together:
- hast ... gelegt = have put / did put
German main-clause word order puts the conjugated verb in second position, so in a question the finite verb comes first:
- Wohin hast du den Schnuller gelegt?
And the past participle usually goes to the end.
Why is it den Schnuller and not der Schnuller?
Because Schnuller is the direct object of legen, and direct objects usually take the accusative case.
The noun is masculine:
- nominative: der Schnuller
- accusative: den Schnuller
So:
- der Schnuller = the pacifier, as subject
- den Schnuller = the pacifier, as object
Here, you are the subject, and the pacifier is the thing being put somewhere, so German uses the accusative:
- du hast den Schnuller gelegt
Why does the second sentence say ihn and not er?
For the same reason: the pacifier is the object of finden, not the subject.
- er = nominative masculine pronoun = he/it as subject
- ihn = accusative masculine pronoun = him/it as object
So:
- Er ist im Kinderbett. = It is in the crib.
- Ich finde ihn nicht. = I can’t find it.
In the sentence:
- Ich finde ihn weder im Kinderbett noch im Hochstuhl.
the speaker is finding or not finding it, so German uses ihn.
What does weder ... noch mean?
Weder ... noch means neither ... nor.
So:
- weder im Kinderbett noch im Hochstuhl = neither in the crib nor in the high chair
It links two negative alternatives.
Examples:
- Ich trinke weder Kaffee noch Tee. = I drink neither coffee nor tea.
- Er ist weder zu Hause noch im Büro. = He is neither at home nor in the office.
It is a fixed pairing, so when you use weder, you normally also use noch later in the sentence.
Why is it im Kinderbett and im Hochstuhl, not ins Kinderbett and in den Hochstuhl?
Because the second sentence is about location, not movement.
German often uses:
- in + accusative for movement into something
- in + dative for being inside something
Compare:
- Du legst den Schnuller ins Kinderbett. = You put the pacifier into the crib.
- movement → accusative
- Der Schnuller ist im Kinderbett. = The pacifier is in the crib.
- location → dative
In your sentence, the speaker says where they cannot find it, so this is a location idea:
- im Kinderbett
- im Hochstuhl
Also, im is just a contraction of in dem.
What is the difference between legen and liegen?
This is a very common German distinction.
- legen = to lay / to put something somewhere
- usually takes an object
- action done by someone
- liegen = to lie / to be lying somewhere
- no direct object
- describes position
Examples:
- Ich lege den Schnuller ins Kinderbett. = I put the pacifier into the crib.
- Der Schnuller liegt im Kinderbett. = The pacifier is lying in the crib.
So in your sentence, gelegt is correct because someone actively put the pacifier somewhere.
Why does the verb come before du in Wohin hast du ...?
Because this is a direct question.
In German yes/no questions and wh-questions, the conjugated verb usually comes very early:
- question word + conjugated verb + subject + rest
So:
- Wohin
- hast
- du
- den Schnuller
- gelegt
- den Schnuller
- du
- hast
That is normal German question word order.
Compare with a statement:
- Du hast den Schnuller ins Kinderbett gelegt.
But as a question:
- Wohin hast du den Schnuller gelegt?
Is Schnuller masculine, and do I just have to memorize that?
Yes, Schnuller is masculine: der Schnuller.
Unfortunately, grammatical gender in German often has to be learned together with the noun. It is best to memorize nouns with their article:
- der Schnuller
- das Kinderbett
- der Hochstuhl
That will help you produce the right case forms later:
- den Schnuller
- im Kinderbett
- im Hochstuhl
Learning the noun without its article usually makes German much harder.
What exactly is gelegt here?
Gelegt is the past participle of legen.
The basic forms are:
- infinitive: legen
- simple past: legte
- past participle: gelegt
In the Perfekt, German uses the past participle with haben:
- ich habe gelegt
- du hast gelegt
So:
- Wohin hast du den Schnuller gelegt?
Literally, it is something like Where have you put the pacifier?, though in natural English it is often simply Where did you put the pacifier?
Could German also say this with nicht ... und nicht instead of weder ... noch?
Yes, but weder ... noch is the more natural and compact structure for neither ... nor.
Compare:
- Ich finde ihn weder im Kinderbett noch im Hochstuhl.
- Ich finde ihn nicht im Kinderbett und nicht im Hochstuhl.
The second version is understandable, but it sounds heavier and less elegant. Native speakers would usually prefer weder ... noch here.
Why doesn’t the second sentence use auch nicht or another extra negative word?
Because weder ... noch already carries the negative meaning by itself.
So:
- Ich finde ihn weder im Kinderbett noch im Hochstuhl.
already means the speaker cannot find it in either place. You do not need an extra nicht there.
German allows different negative structures, but weder ... noch is a complete and standard one on its own.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Wohin hast du den Schnuller gelegt? Ich finde ihn weder im Kinderbett noch im Hochstuhl to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions