Breakdown of Mein Bruder sagt, der neue Stuhl kratzt auf dem Boden, wenn man ihn bewegt.
Questions & Answers about Mein Bruder sagt, der neue Stuhl kratzt auf dem Boden, wenn man ihn bewegt.
Why is there a comma after sagt?
Because the rest of the sentence is a clause giving the content of what the brother says.
German uses a comma before:
- a subordinate clause, such as wenn man ihn bewegt
- and also before a content clause after verbs like sagen, denken, wissen, etc.
Here, Mein Bruder sagt, ... introduces what he says.
You could also say:
- Mein Bruder sagt, dass der neue Stuhl auf dem Boden kratzt, wenn man ihn bewegt.
In your sentence, dass is simply omitted.
Why is dass missing after sagt?
German often leaves out dass after verbs like sagen, especially in everyday speech and writing.
So these are both possible:
- Mein Bruder sagt, der neue Stuhl kratzt auf dem Boden, wenn man ihn bewegt.
- Mein Bruder sagt, dass der neue Stuhl auf dem Boden kratzt, wenn man ihn bewegt.
There is a word-order difference:
- without dass: the next clause has normal main-clause word order
→ der neue Stuhl kratzt ... - with dass: the verb goes to the end
→ dass der neue Stuhl ... kratzt
Why is it der neue Stuhl and not den neuen Stuhl?
Because der neue Stuhl is the subject of the clause der neue Stuhl kratzt ...
The subject is in the nominative case.
- der neue Stuhl = nominative masculine
- den neuen Stuhl = accusative masculine
Here, the chair is the thing doing the action of kratzt, so it must be nominative.
Why does neue end in -e?
Because the adjective neu comes after the definite article der and describes a masculine nominative singular noun: Stuhl.
The pattern is:
- der neue Stuhl
- den neuen Stuhl
- dem neuen Stuhl
So in der neue Stuhl, the adjective takes -e.
What does kratzt mean here exactly?
Here kratzt means something like scrapes or makes a scratching sound.
The verb kratzen literally means to scratch, but with furniture and floors it often means that something rubs against the surface and makes that unpleasant scraping noise.
So der neue Stuhl kratzt auf dem Boden means the chair scrapes against the floor when moved.
Why is it auf dem Boden and not auf den Boden?
Because auf is a two-way preposition and can take either:
- dative for location
- accusative for direction/movement toward a place
Here, the idea is that the chair is scraping on the floor, meaning the floor is the surface where the scraping happens. That is a location, so German uses the dative:
- auf dem Boden
Compare:
- Der Stuhl steht auf dem Boden. = The chair is on the floor.
- Ich stelle den Stuhl auf den Boden. = I put the chair onto the floor.
Why is dem Boden dative?
It is dative because of auf used in a location sense.
Boden is masculine, and the dative singular form with the definite article is:
- dem Boden
So:
- auf dem Boden = on the floor
This is a very common pattern with two-way prepositions in German.
Why is there another comma before wenn?
Because wenn man ihn bewegt is a subordinate clause, and German normally separates subordinate clauses with commas.
The word wenn means when or whenever, and it sends the verb to the end:
- wenn man ihn bewegt
So the comma is required.
Why is the verb at the end in wenn man ihn bewegt?
Because wenn introduces a subordinate clause.
In German subordinate clauses, the conjugated verb usually goes to the end.
So:
- main clause: man bewegt ihn
- subordinate clause: wenn man ihn bewegt
That is one of the most important word-order rules in German.
What does man mean here?
Man means one, you, people, or someone in general.
It does not mean man as in adult male here.
So wenn man ihn bewegt means:
- when you move it
- when someone moves it
- when it is moved
English usually uses you or a passive construction instead of one in everyday speech.
Why is it ihn?
Ihn refers back to den Stuhl.
Stuhl is a masculine noun, so its pronoun forms are:
- nominative: er
- accusative: ihn
- dative: ihm
In man ihn bewegt, the chair is the direct object of bewegt, so the accusative is needed:
- ihn
Could German also say wenn er bewegt wird instead?
Yes. That would be a passive version:
- ..., wenn er bewegt wird.
That means when it is moved.
Your original sentence uses the more general active construction with man:
- wenn man ihn bewegt
Both are natural, but man is often very common in everyday German.
Why is bewegt at the end and not ihn?
Because in a subordinate clause introduced by wenn, the conjugated verb goes to the end, while pronouns and other objects stay earlier in the clause.
So the order is:
- wenn
- subject + object + verb
- wenn man ihn bewegt
That is normal German subordinate-clause word order.
Could the sentence also be Mein Bruder sagt, dass der neue Stuhl auf dem Boden kratzt, wenn man ihn bewegt?
Yes, absolutely.
That version is fully correct and means the same thing.
The main difference is structure:
- Mein Bruder sagt, der neue Stuhl kratzt ...
= dass omitted, following clause keeps main-clause order - Mein Bruder sagt, dass der neue Stuhl ... kratzt ...
= explicit subordinate clause with dass, verb moves to the end
Learners should understand both, because both are very common.
Is wenn here when or if?
Here it means when or whenever.
The idea is: each time the chair is moved, it scrapes on the floor.
German wenn can sometimes mean if, but in this sentence it is clearly about a repeated situation:
- wenn man ihn bewegt = when/whenever you move it
If the sentence were about a more hypothetical condition, English might translate wenn as if depending on context.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Mein Bruder sagt, der neue Stuhl kratzt auf dem Boden, wenn man ihn bewegt to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions