Breakdown of Meine Cousine isst vegan, aber ihre Schwester kocht nur manchmal vegetarisch.
Questions & Answers about Meine Cousine isst vegan, aber ihre Schwester kocht nur manchmal vegetarisch.
Why is it meine Cousine and ihre Schwester?
Because meine and ihre are possessive words, like my and her in English.
Here they both describe feminine singular nouns in the nominative case:
- die Cousine → meine Cousine
- die Schwester → ihre Schwester
The ending -e matches that form.
Compare:
- mein Cousin = my male cousin
- meine Cousine = my female cousin
- ihr Bruder = her brother
- ihre Schwester = her sister
Why does German use Cousine instead of just one word like English cousin?
German usually distinguishes male and female cousins:
- der Cousin = male cousin
- die Cousine = female cousin
English uses cousin for both, but German often makes the gender clear in the noun itself.
Why are vegan and vegetarisch not changed here? Why not something like vegane or vegetarische?
Because in this sentence, vegan and vegetarisch are being used adverbially, not directly before a noun.
So:
- vegan essen = to eat vegan / to eat a vegan diet
- vegetarisch kochen = to cook vegetarian food
There is no noun right after them, so they do not take adjective endings here.
Compare:
- Sie isst vegan. = She eats vegan.
Sie isst veganes Essen. = She eats vegan food.
- Er kocht vegetarisch. = He cooks vegetarian.
- Er kocht vegetarische Gerichte. = He cooks vegetarian dishes.
Why does the sentence say kocht nur manchmal vegetarisch instead of isst nur manchmal vegetarisch?
Because kochen and essen express different ideas.
- isst vegan means your cousin’s eating habits are vegan.
- kocht nur manchmal vegetarisch means her sister only cooks vegetarian food sometimes.
This does not necessarily mean the sister herself is vegetarian. It only tells you something about what she cooks, and how often.
If you said:
- Ihre Schwester isst nur manchmal vegetarisch, that would mean she only eats vegetarian food sometimes.
So the choice of verb changes the meaning quite a bit.
What exactly does nur manchmal mean?
Nur manchmal means only sometimes.
- manchmal = sometimes
- nur = only
Together, they limit the frequency:
- kocht nur manchmal vegetarisch = cooks vegetarian only sometimes
So the sister does it occasionally, not regularly.
Why is nur manchmal placed after kocht?
In a normal German main clause, the finite verb usually stays in second position.
So in:
- ... aber ihre Schwester kocht nur manchmal vegetarisch
the structure is:
- ihre Schwester = subject
- kocht = verb
- nur manchmal vegetarisch = the rest of the sentence
That is very normal German word order.
You could move parts around for emphasis, but the version in the sentence is the most natural neutral order.
Why doesn’t aber send the verb to the end?
Because aber is a coordinating conjunction, like but in English.
It connects two main clauses, so both clauses keep normal main-clause word order:
- Meine Cousine isst vegan
- aber ihre Schwester kocht nur manchmal vegetarisch
The verb stays in second position in both parts.
Compare that with a subordinating conjunction like weil:
- ..., weil ihre Schwester nur manchmal vegetarisch kocht.
There, the verb kocht goes to the end.
Could ihre Schwester mean something other than her sister?
Yes, ihre can sometimes mean different things depending on context, such as:
- her
- their
- sometimes even formal your
But in this sentence, the natural meaning is her sister, referring back to meine Cousine.
So:
- Meine Cousine ... aber ihre Schwester ... most naturally means:
- My cousin ... but her sister ...
Context usually makes this clear.
Why are Cousine and Schwester capitalized?
Because all nouns are capitalized in German.
So in this sentence:
- Cousine is a noun
- Schwester is a noun
That is why they begin with capital letters.
This is a basic rule in German, unlike English, where common nouns are usually not capitalized.
Is the present tense here talking about right now, or about a general habit?
It is talking about a general habit or usual behavior.
- Meine Cousine isst vegan = My cousin eats vegan / follows a vegan diet
- ihre Schwester kocht nur manchmal vegetarisch = her sister only sometimes cooks vegetarian
German present tense often covers both:
- what is happening now
- what usually happens
In this sentence, the meaning is clearly habitual, not just about one specific meal right now.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Meine Cousine isst vegan, aber ihre Schwester kocht nur manchmal vegetarisch to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions