Breakdown of Meine Schwester sagt, sie wolle einerseits Geld sparen, andererseits aber nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten.
Questions & Answers about Meine Schwester sagt, sie wolle einerseits Geld sparen, andererseits aber nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten.
Why is it wolle and not will?
Wolle is the Konjunktiv I form of wollen. In German, Konjunktiv I is often used for reported speech or indirect speech.
So:
- sie will = she wants
- sie wolle = she says she wants / it is reported that she wants
Using wolle creates a little distance: the speaker is reporting what the sister said, not directly stating it as their own fact.
In other words:
- Meine Schwester sagt, sie will ... = more direct, more everyday
- Meine Schwester sagt, sie wolle ... = more formal, more clearly reported speech
Is this sentence an example of indirect speech?
Yes. This is a classic example of indirect speech.
Direct speech would be something like:
- Meine Schwester sagt: Ich will einerseits Geld sparen, andererseits aber nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten.
Indirect speech reports that content from the outside:
- Meine Schwester sagt, sie wolle ...
The pronoun changes from ich to sie, and the verb changes to Konjunktiv I.
Why is there no dass after sagt?
German has two common ways to report what someone says:
with dass
- Meine Schwester sagt, dass sie ... will.
without dass, using Konjunktiv I
- Meine Schwester sagt, sie wolle ...
Both are correct. The version without dass is especially common in more formal written German, journalism, and careful reporting.
So the structure here is not strange; it is just a more formal way of reporting speech.
What would change if the sentence used dass?
If you add dass, the clause becomes a normal subordinate clause, so the finite verb goes to the end.
For example:
- Meine Schwester sagt, dass sie einerseits Geld sparen, andererseits aber nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten will.
Notice the difference:
- without dass: sie wolle ...
- with dass: sie ... will
So two things change:
- the verb form usually goes back to the normal indicative (will)
- the finite verb moves to the end of the dass clause
What exactly does einerseits ... andererseits mean?
It is a fixed pair that means something like:
- on the one hand ... on the other hand
- in one respect ... in another respect
It introduces two contrasting sides of the same situation.
Here:
- einerseits Geld sparen = on the one hand, save money
- andererseits aber nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten = on the other hand, not give up the language course
This pair is very common in German for expressing a tension or conflict between two goals.
Why is aber used after andererseits?
Aber adds extra contrast. The pair einerseits ... andererseits already shows opposition, so aber is not absolutely necessary, but it is very natural.
Compare:
- einerseits ..., andererseits ... = balanced contrast
- einerseits ..., andererseits aber ... = slightly stronger contrast
So here aber emphasizes that the second point goes against the first one.
Why is there only one wolle? Shouldn’t the second half also have a verb?
Good question. The sentence is using one wolle for both infinitive phrases.
The structure is basically:
- sie wolle [einerseits Geld sparen], [andererseits aber nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten]
So the second half does not repeat wolle, because it is understood.
A fuller version would be:
- Meine Schwester sagt, sie wolle einerseits Geld sparen, andererseits wolle sie aber nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten.
That is also grammatical, but more repetitive. German often leaves out repeated material when it is clear from the context.
Why is it auf den Sprachkurs verzichten? Why auf, and why den?
The verb verzichten is used with the preposition auf:
- auf etwas verzichten = to do without something / to give something up
This verb-preposition combination requires the accusative case. That is why we get:
- der Sprachkurs → auf den Sprachkurs
So:
- nominative: der Sprachkurs
- accusative after auf verzichten: den Sprachkurs
This is something you usually just have to learn together as a unit:
- verzichten auf + accusative
Why is nicht placed before auf den Sprachkurs verzichten?
Because nicht is negating the infinitive phrase auf den Sprachkurs verzichten.
The idea is:
- she wants not to give up the language course
So nicht comes right before the part being negated:
- nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten
If the sentence were arranged differently, the focus of the negation could change. Here the meaning is very clear: the thing she does not want to do is give up the language course.
Why is it Geld sparen without an article?
In German, many abstract or mass nouns are used without an article when speaking generally. Geld here means money in a general sense, not some specific money.
So:
- Geld sparen = to save money
This works just like in English, where you also usually say save money, not save the money, unless you mean specific money already mentioned.
Is wolle something people really say in everyday German?
Usually, everyday spoken German is less formal. Many speakers would simply say:
- Meine Schwester sagt, sie will einerseits Geld sparen, andererseits aber nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten.
That sounds very natural in conversation.
Wolle is more typical of:
- formal writing
- journalism
- reported statements
- careful or official-style language
So yes, it is real German, but it has a more formal/reporting flavor than casual speech.
Why is there a comma after sagt?
Because a new clause begins there:
- Meine Schwester sagt,
- sie wolle ...
German uses commas to separate clauses more consistently than English does. Here the comma marks the boundary between the main clause and the reported clause.
So even without dass, the comma is still required.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Meine Schwester sagt, sie wolle einerseits Geld sparen, andererseits aber nicht auf den Sprachkurs verzichten to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions