Breakdown of Im November hat mein Schwiegervater gesagt, dass er gern länger bleiben würde.
Questions & Answers about Im November hat mein Schwiegervater gesagt, dass er gern länger bleiben würde.
Why is it im November and not in November or am November?
Im is a contraction of in dem.
With months in German, the usual expression is im + month:
- im November
- im Januar
- im Sommer
So im November means in November.
Why not am?
Because am is more commonly used with:
- days: am Montag
- dates: am 3. November
Also, November is in the dative here because of in dem → im.
Why is hat right after Im November?
German main clauses follow the verb-second rule.
That means the finite verb must come in the second position. In this sentence, Im November is placed first, so the finite verb hat must come next:
- Im November | hat | mein Schwiegervater gesagt ...
If you started with the subject instead, you would get:
- Mein Schwiegervater hat im November gesagt, ...
Both are correct. The first version emphasizes the time a bit more.
Why does German use hat gesagt here instead of a simple past form like sagte?
Hat gesagt is the Perfekt tense, and sagte is the Präteritum.
In modern spoken German, the Perfekt is very common for talking about past events:
- hat gesagt = very normal in speech
The Präteritum is more common in writing, storytelling, and with a few very common verbs such as war, hatte, konnte, wollte, etc.
So these are both possible:
- Im November hat mein Schwiegervater gesagt, ...
- Im November sagte mein Schwiegervater, ...
The first sounds especially natural in everyday conversation.
Why are November and Schwiegervater capitalized?
Because they are nouns, and in German all nouns are capitalized.
So:
- November = noun
- Schwiegervater = noun
This is one of the big spelling differences between English and German.
Why is there a comma before dass?
Because dass introduces a subordinate clause, and in German subordinate clauses are normally separated by a comma.
So the structure is:
- main clause: Im November hat mein Schwiegervater gesagt
- subordinate clause: dass er gern länger bleiben würde
That comma is required in standard German.
What does dass do in this sentence?
Dass means that and introduces the content of what was said.
So the sentence structure is basically:
- He said that ...
In German, when dass starts a subordinate clause, it also changes the word order: the finite verb goes to the end of that clause.
That is why you get:
- dass er ... bleiben würde
instead of the main-clause order:
- er würde ... bleiben
Why does the clause after dass end with würde?
Because after dass, German uses subordinate clause word order, and the finite verb goes to the end.
Here, the finite verb is würde.
So:
- main-clause order: Er würde gern länger bleiben.
- subordinate-clause order: dass er gern länger bleiben würde
This is one of the most important German word-order patterns to learn.
Why is it bleiben würde and not würde bleiben?
Because this clause has a two-verb structure:
- würde = finite verb
- bleiben = infinitive
In a main clause, the finite verb comes early:
- Er würde gern länger bleiben.
In a subordinate clause with dass, the verb cluster goes to the end, and the infinitive usually comes before the finite verb:
- dass er gern länger bleiben würde
So bleiben würde is exactly what you expect at the end of a dass clause.
What does würde mean here?
Here würde + infinitive is the Konjunktiv II form.
In this sentence, it expresses something like:
- a wish
- a tentative statement
- something like English would
So gern länger bleiben würde is roughly the idea of would like to stay longer or would gladly stay longer.
It does not necessarily mean a real conditional like if X happened, then.... In sentences like this, würde often softens the statement and makes it sound less direct.
What does gern mean here? Is gerne also correct?
Gern means gladly.
Very often, German uses gern where English uses like to:
- Ich trinke gern Kaffee. = I like drinking coffee.
- Ich würde gern bleiben. = I would like to stay.
So in this sentence, gern helps create the meaning would like to.
Yes, gerne is also correct.
Gern and gerne mean the same thing. Gern is just slightly shorter and very common.
So both are natural:
- dass er gern länger bleiben würde
- dass er gerne länger bleiben würde
What does länger mean here, and why does it have an umlaut?
Länger means longer.
It is the comparative form of lang:
- lang = long
- länger = longer
In this sentence, it functions adverbially and describes bleiben:
- länger bleiben = stay longer
The umlaut is part of the normal comparative formation for some adjectives/adverbs in German:
- alt → älter
- jung → jünger
- lang → länger
So länger is just the correct comparative form.
Could this sentence also be said in another natural way?
Yes. A few alternatives are possible, but the nuance can change.
For example:
Im November hat mein Schwiegervater gesagt, dass er länger bleiben möchte.
This is also very natural and often a bit more directly like would like to stay longer.Im November sagte mein Schwiegervater, dass er gern länger bleiben würde.
Same basic meaning, but more literary or written because of sagte.Mein Schwiegervater hat im November gesagt, dass er gern länger bleiben würde.
Same meaning, just a different word order in the main clause.
So the original sentence is completely natural, but German often allows different versions depending on style and emphasis.
More from this lesson
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Im November hat mein Schwiegervater gesagt, dass er gern länger bleiben würde to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions