Meine Freundin träumt von einer Zukunft, in der jede Burg ein offenes Museum ist und im Innenhof Konzerte in völliger Stille beginnen.

Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.

Start learning German now

Questions & Answers about Meine Freundin träumt von einer Zukunft, in der jede Burg ein offenes Museum ist und im Innenhof Konzerte in völliger Stille beginnen.

Why is it träumt von einer Zukunft and not träumt über eine Zukunft or just träumt eine Zukunft?

In German, träumen almost always takes the preposition von when you talk about what someone dreams of (both literally and metaphorically):

  • von etwas träumen = to dream of something

So:

  • Sie träumt von einer Zukunft. = She dreams of a future.

träumen über is possible but rare, and usually used only for dreams you had while sleeping, mostly in the sense of “to dream about a topic” in a more descriptive way, e.g.:

  • Ich habe über meine Kindheit geträumt.
    (I had a dream about my childhood.)

You cannot say sie träumt eine Zukunft; träumen doesn’t take a direct object in that sense in German. You need the preposition von plus dative.

Why is it von einer Zukunft (dative) and not von eine Zukunft?

The preposition von in German always takes the dative case.

  • von + die Zukunft (feminine, nominative)
    von der Zukunft (dative, definite)
  • von + eine Zukunft (feminine, nominative)
    von einer Zukunft (dative, indefinite)

In the sentence we have an indefinite future (“a” future, not “the” future), so:

  • von einer Zukunft = of a future

If you used the definite article (talking about a specific, known future), it would be:

  • von der Zukunft = of the future

But von eine Zukunft is grammatically wrong because von cannot be followed by the nominative.

What does in der refer to, and why do we use der instead of die?

in der here starts a relative clause:

  • ..., in der jede Burg ein offenes Museum ist und ...

in der = “in which”. The word der is a relative pronoun referring back to Zukunft.

Step by step:

  1. Zukunft is feminine: die Zukunft.
  2. In the relative clause we conceptually say:
    in der Zukunft = in the future.
  3. in can take dative or accusative. Here it describes being within a time period, so it’s dative.
  4. Feminine dative singular of die is der.

So:

  • main noun: (die) Zukunft
  • reference back to it in dative: in der (Zukunft)
  • relative pronoun: in der, meaning “in which”.

That’s why it’s in der, not in die.

Why do ist and beginnen go at the end of their parts of the sentence?

Because they are inside a relative clause, which is a type of subordinate clause in German. In subordinate clauses, the conjugated verb goes to the end.

The relative clause is everything after the comma:

  • in der jede Burg ein offenes Museum ist
    und im Innenhof Konzerte in völliger Stille beginnen.

Both ist and beginnen are the conjugated verbs of their respective parts, so they appear at the end of those parts.

If these were independent main clauses, you would have verb-second (V2) word order:

  • Jede Burg ist ein offenes Museum.
  • Im Innenhof beginnen Konzerte in völliger Stille.

But inside the relative clause introduced by in der, you must use verb‑final order.

Why is it jede Burg and not jedes Burg or jeder Burg?

The choice of jede / jeder / jedes depends on the gender and case of the noun.

  • Burg is feminine: die Burg.
  • Here Burg is the subject of the clause “jede Burg ist …”, so it’s nominative.

Feminine nominative singular with jede is:

  • jede Burg = each castle / every castle

For comparison:

  • masculine nominative: jeder Mann
  • neuter nominative: jedes Haus
  • feminine nominative: jede Burg

So jedes Burg and jeder Burg are incorrect because they use endings for the wrong gender/case.

What is the difference between Burg and Schloss in German?

Both often get translated as “castle”, but there’s a nuance:

  • die Burg: usually a medieval fortress, built mainly for defense. Often on a hill, with thick walls, towers, etc. (e.g. Burg Hohenzollern).
  • das Schloss: more like a palace or stately residence, built mainly for representation and comfort, less for military defense (e.g. Schloss Neuschwanstein).

So in this sentence, Burg suggests historic, fortress‑like castles rather than palaces.

Why is it ein offenes Museum and not ein offen Museum or ein offene Museum?

Here offenes is an adjective modifying Museum, and it needs the correct adjective ending.

  • Museum is neuter: das Museum.
  • In the clause jede Burg ein offenes Museum ist,
    the phrase ein offenes Museum is a predicate noun phrase in the nominative (it describes what the Burg is).
  • Nominative neuter with an indefinite article (ein) → adjective ending -es.

Result:

  • ein offenes Museum

Comparisons:

  • ein offenes Museum (neuter nominative, indefinite)
  • das offene Museum (neuter nominative, definite)
  • Museen sind offen (here offen is a predicate adjective, no ending, because there is no article + noun after it)

So:
ein offen Museum and ein offene Museum are wrong; the correct form is ein offenes Museum.

What exactly is im Innenhof, and why not in dem Innenhof?

im is simply the contracted form of in dem:

  • in + demim

Innenhof is masculine: der Innenhof (“inner courtyard”).
Because it’s a location (where something happens), in takes the dative case:

  • in dem Innenhof (dative masculine)
    → contracted: im Innenhof

Both in dem Innenhof and im Innenhof are grammatically correct; in normal speech and writing, the contracted im is far more common.

Why is Konzerte used without any article? Could we also say die Konzerte?

In German, plural nouns can often appear without an article when you talk about them in a general or indefinite way:

  • Konzerte beginnen im Innenhof.
    = Concerts (in general, some concerts) start in the courtyard.

In the sentence, Konzerte in völliger Stille beginnen means something like “concerts (there) begin in complete silence”, not specific, already-known concerts.

If you said die Konzerte, you would be referring to specific concerts that speaker and listener already know about:

  • … und im Innenhof beginnen die Konzerte in völliger Stille.
    = and in the courtyard, the concerts (which we have in mind) begin in complete silence.

So both forms are possible, but without an article is more neutral and general.

Why is it in völliger Stille and not in völlige Stille?

The preposition in can take either:

  • dative = location/state (where/how something is)
  • accusative = direction (movement into something)

Here we describe the state/condition in which the concerts begin: in complete silence, not a movement into silence. So we use dative.

  • Stille is feminine: die Stille.
  • Dative feminine singular without an article → adjective has strong ending -er.

So:

  • in völliger Stille = in complete silence (dative feminine singular)
  • in die Stille (accusative) would mean a movement into the silence, which doesn’t fit “begin in silence”.

That’s why it’s völliger (dative) and not völlige (accusative).

Why is there a comma before in der?

In German, relative clauses are separated from the main clause by commas.

  • Main clause: Meine Freundin träumt von einer Zukunft
  • Relative clause describing Zukunft: in der jede Burg ein offenes Museum ist und im Innenhof Konzerte in völliger Stille beginnen.

So you must write:

  • Meine Freundin träumt von einer Zukunft, in der …

Relative clauses almost always start with a relative pronoun (here: der) and are introduced by a comma.

Does Freundin here mean “girlfriend” or just “female friend”? How do Germans tell the difference?

Freundin can mean both:

  • (die) Freundin = female friend
  • (meine) Freundin = often “my girlfriend”, depending on context

In many modern contexts, meine Freundin is first understood as “my girlfriend” unless the situation clearly suggests otherwise (for example, in school when talking about classmates: “Eine Freundin von mir …” often means “a female friend of mine”).

Ways to make it clearer:

  • romantic partner
    • meine feste Freundin (my steady girlfriend)
    • meine Partnerin
  • non-romantic female friend
    • eine Freundin von mir (a friend of mine)
    • meine gute Freundin (my good (female) friend), often still ambiguous but context helps.

In isolation, Meine Freundin träumt … would usually be understood as “My girlfriend dreams …”.

Why are words like Freundin, Zukunft, Burg, Museum, Innenhof, Konzerte, Stille capitalized?

In German, all nouns are capitalized, regardless of whether they’re proper names or common nouns.

So in the sentence:

  • Freundin, Zukunft, Burg, Museum, Innenhof, Konzerte, Stille

are all nouns and therefore capitalized.

Adjectives like offenes, völliger are not capitalized (unless they are part of a title or have been turned into nouns, e.g. das Offene).