Breakdown of Je leur écris un message pour confirmer le dîner.
Questions & Answers about Je leur écris un message pour confirmer le dîner.
Why is it leur and not ils or eux?
French uses different pronouns depending on the function in the sentence.
- Ils = subject pronoun: Ils viennent. (They are coming.)
- Eux = stressed/disjunctive pronoun, used after prepositions or for emphasis: Je parle avec eux. (I’m talking with them.)
- Leur (here) = indirect object pronoun, meaning to them, used before the verb: Je leur écris. (I am writing to them.)
In Je leur écris un message, leur replaces à eux (to them), so leur is the correct choice, not ils or eux.
What exactly does leur mean here, and why is there no à in the sentence?
Why is it Je leur écris un message and not Je écris leur un message?
In French, unstressed object pronouns (like me, te, lui, nous, vous, leur, le, la, les) go before the conjugated verb, in a fixed order.
Basic pattern:
subject + (object pronoun) + verb
So:
- Je leur écris un message ✅
- Je écris leur un message ❌ (wrong position)
English word order doesn’t work here; you must put leur before écris.
Does Je leur écris un message mean “I write them a message” or “I am writing them a message”?
Can I say Je leur écris pour confirmer le dîner and skip un message?
Yes, absolutely.
Je leur écris un message pour confirmer le dîner.
Focuses on the medium: you are sending a message (not calling, not visiting, etc.).Je leur écris pour confirmer le dîner.
More general: you are writing to them (email, text, etc.) to confirm.
Both are correct; the second is often more natural in conversation because you don’t always need to mention un message explicitly.
Why is confirmer in the infinitive after pour?
Pour + infinitive is a common structure meaning in order to + verb.
- Je leur écris un message pour confirmer le dîner.
= I am writing them a message (in order) to confirm the dinner.
Other examples:
- Je prends le bus pour aller au travail. (…to go to work)
- Il étudie pour réussir l’examen. (…to pass the exam)
So pour confirmer is the normal way to express to confirm as a purpose.
Why is it le dîner and not un dîner or just dîner without an article?
Here dîner is a noun, meaning the dinner (a specific dinner that both speaker and listener know about, e.g. a planned dinner).
- le dîner = the specific dinner we’re referring to
- un dîner = a dinner (non-specific, one of many)
- dîner without an article is usually the verb:
- Nous allons dîner. (We are going to have dinner.)
In pour confirmer le dîner, the definite article le shows that it is a particular, already-arranged event.
Is dîner here a noun or a verb, and what’s the difference?
In this sentence, dîner is a noun:
- le dîner = the dinner (meal/event)
As a verb, dîner means to have dinner / to dine:
- Nous dînons à 20 h. (We have dinner at 8 p.m.)
- On va dîner chez Paul. (We’re going to have dinner at Paul’s place.)
So:
- Je leur écris un message pour confirmer le dîner.
→ dîner = noun (with article le) - Je leur écris pour dîner avec eux.
→ dîner = verb (infinitive, no article)
How would the sentence change if I were writing to just one person (him or her) instead of several people?
How could I say “I’m writing it to them” using only pronouns?
First, identify the two objects:
- un message → le (direct object pronoun, masculine singular)
- à eux → leur (indirect object pronoun)
The order of object pronouns before a single conjugated verb is:
So:
- Je le leur écris.
= I’m writing it to them.
This replaces Je leur écris un message when the context already makes un message clear.
Can I use other words instead of un message, like “a text” or “an email”?
Can I use pour to mean “to someone” in this sentence, like J’écris un message pour eux?
Be careful here; pour and à don’t work the same way with écrire:
écrire un message pour quelqu’un usually means you write a message for someone’s benefit / on their behalf, not that they are the recipient.
In Je leur écris un message, leur clearly marks them as the recipients. If you say J’écris un message pour eux, it can sound like you’re doing it for them, but not necessarily to them. Context is needed, and the nuance is different.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Je leur écris un message pour confirmer le dîner to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions