Breakdown of De arts zegt dat de wond schoon moet blijven en dat het verband morgen vervangen moet worden.
Questions & Answers about De arts zegt dat de wond schoon moet blijven en dat het verband morgen vervangen moet worden.
Why is dat used after zegt?
After a verb like zeggen (to say), Dutch normally introduces the reported statement with dat. It works like English that in The doctor says that....
One important difference from English: Dutch usually keeps dat, while English often leaves that out. So Dutch strongly prefers De arts zegt dat..., not just De arts zegt... followed immediately by the clause.
Why is dat repeated after en?
Because the sentence contains two coordinated subordinate clauses:
- dat de wond schoon moet blijven
- dat het verband morgen vervangen moet worden
Repeating dat is very natural and helps make the structure clear. In English, you might say that ... and that ... or sometimes omit the second that. In Dutch, repeating dat is especially common, and here it sounds better because the second clause has a different subject: de wond vs het verband.
Why does zegt come near the beginning, but moet comes near the end?
This is the difference between a main clause and a subordinate clause.
In the main clause, Dutch usually follows the verb-second rule:
- De arts zegt ...
The finite verb zegt is in second position.
After dat, you get a subordinate clause, and in subordinate clauses the finite verb usually moves toward the end:
- dat de wond schoon moet blijven
- dat het verband morgen vervangen moet worden
So the unusual-looking word order is caused by dat.
Why is it moet blijven?
This is a modal construction:
- moet = must / has to
- blijven = stay / remain
Together, moet blijven means must stay or must remain.
Dutch modals work a lot like English ones:
must stay, can go, will come
=
moet blijven, kan gaan, zal komen
Why is there no te before blijven or worden?
Because Dutch modal verbs take a bare infinitive, just like English.
So you say:
- moet blijven
- moet worden
- kan komen
not:
- moet te blijven
- moet te worden
This is similar to English must stay, not must to stay.
Why is schoon placed before moet blijven?
Because schoon is the predicate adjective that goes with blijven: to stay clean.
So:
- de wond blijft schoon = the wound stays clean
- de wond schoon moet blijven = the wound must stay clean
In the subordinate clause, the adjective stays before the final verb cluster. That is why schoon comes before moet blijven.
Why are there three verbs in vervangen moet worden?
Because this part is a passive construction with a modal.
- moet = must / has to
- worden = be, used to form the passive
- vervangen = replaced
So vervangen moet worden means must be replaced.
You can think of it like this:
- active: Iemand moet het verband vervangen = Someone must replace the bandage
- passive: Het verband moet vervangen worden = The bandage must be replaced
In the subordinate clause, the verbs collect at the end.
Is vervangen here an infinitive or a past participle?
Here it functions as the past participle in the passive construction, even though it looks identical to the infinitive.
That happens with many Dutch verbs that have an inseparable prefix, such as vervangen. Their past participle often has the same form as the infinitive.
Compare:
- infinitive: Ik wil het verband vervangen = I want to replace the bandage
- participle in passive: Het verband moet vervangen worden = The bandage must be replaced
So the form is the same, but the grammar is different.
Why is worden used and not zijn?
Because worden forms the normal action passive: it focuses on the action of being replaced.
- Het verband moet vervangen worden = The bandage must be replaced
By contrast, zijn usually describes the resulting state:
- Het verband is vervangen = The bandage has been replaced / is replaced
Here the doctor is talking about what needs to happen, so worden is the right choice.
Why is morgen placed before vervangen moet worden?
In Dutch subordinate clauses, adverbs like morgen often appear in the middle part of the clause, before the final verb group.
So:
- dat het verband morgen vervangen moet worden
is the normal order.
In a main clause, you might see:
- Het verband moet morgen vervangen worden
The time word is still before the infinitive/passive part.
Can you also say dat het verband morgen moet worden vervangen?
Yes, you may also hear dat het verband morgen moet worden vervangen. That word order is also possible.
Dutch verb clusters allow some variation, especially in longer combinations like modal + passive. The version in your sentence, vervangen moet worden, is completely normal and idiomatic.
So both are possible, but the exact preference can vary by style and region.
Why is it de arts and de wond, but het verband?
Because Dutch nouns have grammatical gender for article choice:
- de arts
- de wond
- het verband
Arts and wond are de-words.
Verband is a het-word.
Unfortunately, this often has to be learned noun by noun. There are some patterns, but for many everyday nouns the safest approach is to memorize the article together with the noun.
Why does the second part use the passive instead of saying who replaces the bandage?
Because the important thing here is the medical instruction, not the person doing the action.
Dutch, like English, often uses the passive when the agent is unknown, obvious, or unimportant:
- het verband moet vervangen worden = the bandage must be replaced
This sounds more natural in instructions than explicitly naming someone. If needed, Dutch could use an active version, such as:
- ... dat iemand morgen het verband moet vervangen
- ... dat de verpleegkundige morgen het verband moet vervangen
But the passive is the most neutral and typical wording here.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning DutchMaster Dutch — from De arts zegt dat de wond schoon moet blijven en dat het verband morgen vervangen moet worden to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions