Breakdown of Mesnica u susjednoj ulici je otvorena rano.
Questions & Answers about Mesnica u susjednoj ulici je otvorena rano.
What does mesnica mean, and what kind of noun is it?
Mesnica means butcher’s shop or butcher’s.
Grammatically, it is:
- a feminine noun
- singular
- in the nominative case here, because it is the subject of the sentence
That is why other words in the sentence match it as feminine singular.
Why is it otvorena and not otvoren?
Because otvorena has to agree with mesnica.
In Croatian, adjectives and adjective-like forms agree with the noun in:
Since mesnica is feminine singular, the form is:
- masculine: otvoren
- feminine: otvorena
- neuter: otvoreno
So mesnica je otvorena = the butcher’s shop is open.
Why do we say u susjednoj ulici?
Because this phrase means in/on the neighboring street, and after u when talking about a location, Croatian uses the locative case.
The base forms are:
- susjedna = neighboring
- ulica = street
But in the locative singular they become:
- susjednoj
- ulici
So:
- susjedna ulica = a neighboring street
- u susjednoj ulici = in/on the neighboring street
Both the adjective and the noun change, because they must match in case, gender, and number.
Why does u take the locative here? Doesn’t u sometimes take the accusative?
Yes. U can take either locative or accusative, depending on meaning.
- u + locative = location, being somewhere
- u + accusative = motion into somewhere
Here the butcher’s shop is already located there, so Croatian uses locative:
- u susjednoj ulici = in/on the neighboring street
Compare:
- Mesnica je u susjednoj ulici. = The butcher’s shop is in the neighboring street.
- Idem u susjednu ulicu. = I’m going into/to the neighboring street.
So the case changes with the idea of location vs movement.
What exactly does je otvorena mean here? Could it also mean was opened?
In this sentence, je otvorena means is open.
That can be confusing, because Croatian uses a form that looks like a past passive participle:
- otvoren / otvorena / otvoreno
So depending on context, je otvorena can sometimes look like:
- is open = a state
- was opened / has been opened = a passive idea
Here, the natural reading is the state:
- Mesnica ... je otvorena rano. = The butcher’s shop ... is open early.
A native speaker understands this from context.
What does rano do here, and why is it not rana?
Rano is an adverb, meaning early.
It describes when the shop is open.
- otvorena rano = open early
It is not rana, because rana would be an adjective form, not an adverb.
Compare:
- rana jutra type adjective use = early mornings
- rano otvara or je otvorena rano = opens early / is open early
A useful pattern is:
- adjective: ran = early
- adverb: rano = early
Why is je in the middle of the sentence?
Because je is a clitic, and Croatian clitics usually go in the second position of the clause.
Very importantly, that means second position after the first whole phrase, not necessarily after the first single word.
In this sentence, the first phrase is:
- Mesnica u susjednoj ulici
Then comes the clitic:
- je
So:
- Mesnica u susjednoj ulici je otvorena rano.
This is normal Croatian word order.
Could the word order be changed?
Yes, Croatian word order is more flexible than English word order.
For example, you may also hear:
- Mesnica u susjednoj ulici rano je otvorena.
That still means the same thing, but the emphasis shifts slightly.
However, not every rearrangement sounds equally natural, and clitics like je still have to follow the usual placement rules. So for a learner, the given sentence is a good neutral model to copy.
Why is it u ulici when English usually says on the street?
Because prepositions do not match one-to-one across languages.
Croatian often uses u where English uses:
- in
- on
- sometimes at
So:
- u ulici literally looks like in the street, but in natural English the best translation may be on the street or in the street, depending on context.
This is normal and just has to be learned as Croatian usage:
- u ulici
- u gradu
- u školi
So do not translate the preposition too literally every time.
Is susjednoj related to susjed?
Yes.
- susjed = neighbor
- susjedna / susjedni = neighboring, adjacent
So susjednoj ulici means the neighboring street or the adjacent street.
This is a common Croatian way to describe something nearby:
- u susjednoj zgradi = in the neighboring building
- u susjednom selu = in the neighboring village
So if you know susjed, the adjective susjedni / susjedna / susjedno is a useful related word to learn.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CroatianMaster Croatian — from Mesnica u susjednoj ulici je otvorena rano to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions