Breakdown of Net omdat studieruimtes sluit, beteken dit nie dat vaktydskrifte verdwyn nie.
Questions & Answers about Net omdat studieruimtes sluit, beteken dit nie dat vaktydskrifte verdwyn nie.
What does net omdat mean here?
Net omdat means just because.
In this sentence, it introduces a reason that someone might wrongly treat as proof of something else:
So net here does not mean only in a strict mathematical sense; it gives the idea of merely or simply.
Why is there a nie ... nie around beteken dit ... dat ... verdwyn?
Afrikaans usually uses a double negative. That is why you see two instances of nie:
- first nie after the finite verb area: beteken dit nie
- second nie at the end of the negative clause: verdwyn nie
So:
- beteken dit nie dat ... verdwyn nie = it does not mean that ... disappear
This is one of the most important grammar patterns in Afrikaans.
Why does sluit stay the same even though studieruimtes is plural?
Because Afrikaans verbs normally do not change form according to the subject.
So you get:
- die studieruimte sluit = the study space closes
- die studieruimtes sluit = the study spaces close
- ek sluit = I close
- ons sluit = we close
Unlike English, Afrikaans does not usually add different endings like close / closes.
Why is the verb at the end in omdat studieruimtes sluit?
Because omdat introduces a subordinate clause, and in Afrikaans subordinate clauses typically push the finite verb toward the end.
So:
- main clause: Studieruimtes sluit.
- subordinate clause: omdat studieruimtes sluit
The same thing happens after dat later in the sentence:
- dat vaktydskrifte verdwyn
This end-position of the verb is very normal after conjunctions like omdat, dat, as, terwyl, and so on.
Why is there a comma after sluit?
The opening part Net omdat studieruimtes sluit is a subordinate clause placed before the main clause.
Afrikaans normally separates such a fronted subordinate clause from the main clause with a comma:
- Net omdat studieruimtes sluit, beteken dit nie ... nie.
So the comma marks the boundary between:
- the reason clause
- the main statement
What is the role of dit in beteken dit nie?
Here dit works like English it in it does not mean that...
It does not refer to one specific physical object. It points back to the whole previous idea:
- Net omdat studieruimtes sluit
- dit = that fact / that situation
So the sentence structure is very close to English:
- Just because study spaces are closing, it does not mean that academic journals are disappearing.
Why is there a dat after beteken dit nie?
What does vaktydskrifte mean literally?
It is a compound noun:
- vak = field, subject, discipline, profession
- tydskrif = magazine, journal, periodical
- vaktydskrif = specialist journal / professional journal / academic periodical
- vaktydskrifte = plural
Afrikaans forms many nouns by combining smaller words like this, just as English can do with words like textbook, newspaper, or classroom.
What is the difference between the two nie words in the sentence?
They work together as one negative frame, but they sit in different places.
In this sentence:
- first nie: after the main clause verb structure
beteken dit nie - second nie: at the end of the clause
verdwyn nie
You can think of it as the sentence being wrapped in negation.
A rough pattern is:
- Subject + verb + nie + rest + nie
But because this sentence contains subordinate clauses, the exact placement looks a little more complex.
Is verdwyn a normal verb form here? Why doesn’t it change?
Could this sentence be translated word-for-word into English?
Not perfectly word-for-word, but it is structurally quite close.
A very literal breakdown would be:
- Net omdat = just because
- studieruimtes sluit = study spaces close / are closing
- beteken dit nie = does it not mean
- dat vaktydskrifte verdwyn nie = that specialist journals disappear not
Natural English would be:
- Just because study spaces are closing, it does not mean that academic journals are disappearing.
So the overall logic is very similar, even though the Afrikaans negative pattern is different.
Could sluit here mean close in the sense of shutting down permanently?
It could, depending on context. Sluit can mean:
- to close for the day
- to be closed
- to shut down
So studieruimtes sluit could mean study spaces are closing, but whether that means temporarily or permanently depends on the wider context.
Afrikaans often leaves that detail to context, just as English sometimes does.
Why isn’t the sentence written with om te or another infinitive construction?
Because this sentence is making a full statement about what is happening, not expressing purpose or an infinitive idea.
It is not saying:
- to close study spaces means...
It is saying:
- because study spaces are closing, it does not mean...
That requires a full finite clause after omdat, so Afrikaans uses:
- omdat studieruimtes sluit
not an infinitive structure.
Is Net omdat X, beteken dit nie dat Y nie a common pattern in Afrikaans?
Yes, very common. It is a standard way to reject a bad conclusion.
Examples of the same pattern:
- Net omdat hy stil is, beteken dit nie dat hy onvriendelik is nie.
Just because he is quiet, it does not mean that he is unfriendly.
- Net omdat dit moeilik is, beteken dit nie dat dit onmoontlik is nie.
- Just because it is difficult, it does not mean that it is impossible.
So this sentence is useful not only for vocabulary, but also as a model pattern you can reuse.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning AfrikaansMaster Afrikaans — from Net omdat studieruimtes sluit, beteken dit nie dat vaktydskrifte verdwyn nie to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions