Breakdown of Dis nie dat hulle praat nie—net dat hulle lees.
Questions & Answers about Dis nie dat hulle praat nie—net dat hulle lees.
What does Dis mean?
Why are there two nies in this sentence?
Afrikaans normally uses a double negative frame:
- the first nie appears earlier in the clause
- the second nie appears near the end of the clause
So in Dis nie dat hulle praat nie:
- first nie comes after is in Dis
- second nie closes the negative clause
These two nies work together. They do not cancel each other out the way two negatives might in logic or in some forms of English.
What does dat do here?
Why is there no separate word for are before praat or lees?
Afrikaans usually does not use a separate verb like English am/is/are to form the ordinary present continuous.
So:
- hulle praat can mean they talk or they are talking
- hulle lees can mean they read or they are reading
Context tells you which meaning is intended.
If you really want to stress that an action is in progress, Afrikaans can use:
- hulle is besig om te lees = they are busy reading / they are reading
But in many ordinary sentences, the simple present is enough.
Why are praat and lees at the end of the dat-clauses?
Are praat and lees present-tense verbs here, or infinitives?
Here they are finite present-tense verbs.
Afrikaans often uses the same basic form for:
- the infinitive
- the present tense
So the form itself does not always tell you the difference. The sentence structure tells you.
In dat hulle praat and dat hulle lees, these are finite verbs because they belong to clauses with a subject, hulle.
What does net mean here?
Net here means just, only, or simply.
So net dat hulle lees means something like:
- just that they are reading
- only that they are reading
It softens or corrects the first idea:
- not that they are talking
- just that they are reading
Why isn’t dis repeated before net dat hulle lees?
It is left out because Afrikaans often omits repeated words when the meaning is already clear.
The fuller version would be:
- Dis nie dat hulle praat nie—dis net dat hulle lees.
But after the dash, dropping the second dis sounds natural and avoids repetition.
This kind of omission is very common in both English and Afrikaans.
What does the dash do in this sentence?
The dash marks a strong contrast or correction.
It signals something like:
- not X — just Y
So the sentence first rejects one explanation, then immediately gives the right one.
A comma could sometimes be used in similar writing, but the dash makes the contrast feel sharper and more deliberate.
Why doesn’t hulle change the verb form?
In Afrikaans, verbs usually do not change form for different persons in the present tense.
So you get:
- ek praat
- jy praat
- hy praat
- hulle praat
The verb stays the same. This is much simpler than English, where you have forms like I read but he reads.
Is Dis nie dat ... nie a fixed pattern I can reuse?
Yes. It is a very useful pattern.
You can use it whenever you want to say It’s not that ...
For example:
Dis nie dat ek moeg is nie; ek is net besig.
= It’s not that I’m tired; I’m just busy.Dis nie dat sy kwaad is nie—sy is net stil.
= It’s not that she’s angry—she’s just quiet.
So the sentence you were given is a good model for a common Afrikaans structure.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning AfrikaansMaster Afrikaans — from Dis nie dat hulle praat nie—net dat hulle lees to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions