Breakdown of Hoe sag pottebakkersklei ook al is, modelleer ons dit.
Questions & Answers about Hoe sag pottebakkersklei ook al is, modelleer ons dit.
What does hoe ... ook al mean in this sentence?
This is a common Afrikaans pattern meaning however ... or no matter how ....
So:
- Hoe sag ... ook al is = However soft ... is
- More naturally in English: No matter how soft ... is
The words ook al do not translate very literally here. Together with hoe, they create a concessive idea: something is true despite that condition.
A few similar patterns:
Why is is at the end of the first clause?
Because Hoe sag pottebakkersklei ook al is is a subordinate clause, and in Afrikaans subordinate clauses normally send the finite verb to the end.
So the order is:
- Hoe sag pottebakkersklei ook al is
- literally something like: however soft potter’s clay also all is
That final is is completely normal in this kind of clause.
Compare:
- Main clause: Die klei is sag. = The clay is soft.
- Subordinate clause: ... omdat die klei sag is. = ... because the clay is soft.
Why does the main clause say modelleer ons dit instead of ons modelleer dit?
This is because Afrikaans main clauses follow the verb-second rule.
The whole first clause, Hoe sag pottebakkersklei ook al is, takes the first position in the sentence. After that, the finite verb of the main clause must come next.
So the structure is:
- Hoe sag pottebakkersklei ook al is = fronted subordinate clause
- modelleer = finite verb
- ons = subject
- dit = object
That gives:
- Hoe sag pottebakkersklei ook al is, modelleer ons dit.
This is very similar to other Afrikaans sentences with something placed first:
What exactly is pottebakkersklei?
It is a compound noun, which Afrikaans often writes as a single word.
It breaks down like this:
- pottebakker = potter
- klei = clay
So pottebakkersklei means potter’s clay, pottery clay, or clay used by a potter.
The -s- in the middle is a linking sound/letter that often appears in compounds. It is not the same as an English apostrophe.
Afrikaans loves compounds, so one long word is very normal.
Why is it sag and not sagte?
Because sag is being used predicatively, not attributively.
Here it is part of the structure:
- pottebakkersklei is sag = potter’s clay is soft
After is, Afrikaans normally uses the basic adjective form:
- Die klei is sag.
- Die water is koud.
- Die kind is gelukkig.
But before a noun, Afrikaans often uses the inflected form:
- sagte klei = soft clay
- koue water = cold water
- gelukkige kind = happy child
So:
- sag = after the verb, as in is sag
- sagte = before the noun, as in sagte klei
Why is there no die before pottebakkersklei?
Because the sentence is talking about pottery clay in a general or material sense, not a specific piece of clay.
Afrikaans often leaves out the article with general materials or substances:
- Water is belangrik.
- Goud is duur.
- Klei is nat.
So pottebakkersklei here means pottery clay in general.
If you were talking about a specific clay, you could say:
- die pottebakkersklei = the pottery clay
But in this sentence, the article is not needed.
What does modelleer mean here? Is it the same as English model?
Why is dit at the end?
What does the comma do here?
The comma separates the fronted subordinate clause from the main clause.
So the sentence has two parts:
The comma helps show that the first part is a dependent clause setting up the idea, and the second part is the main statement.
This is very common in Afrikaans when a subordinate clause comes first:
- As dit reën, bly ons binne.
- Omdat hy moeg is, slaap hy vroeg.
Could I also say Al is pottebakkersklei sag, modelleer ons dit?
Yes, that would also be grammatical, but it is not exactly the same emphasis.
- Hoe sag pottebakkersklei ook al is focuses on the degree of softness: however soft
- Al is pottebakkersklei sag means more generally although potter’s clay is soft
So the original sentence highlights no matter how soft it may be. It is stronger and more specific than a simple although clause.
Is this sentence natural Afrikaans, or does it sound formal/literary?
It is grammatical and natural, but the hoe ... ook al pattern can sound a little more formal, careful, or written than everyday speech.
In normal speech, people might still use it, but they might also choose simpler alternatives depending on the situation.
So a learner should recognize it well, because it is a very useful and standard structure, especially in writing and formal spoken Afrikaans.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning AfrikaansMaster Afrikaans — from Hoe sag pottebakkersklei ook al is, modelleer ons dit to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions