Question 1

Why does it use cuyo instead of matching the singer's gender?

Accepted Answer

In Spanish, cuyo (whose) acts like an adjective, so it must match the gender and number of the thing being possessed, not the person who owns it. Since talento (talent) is singular and masculine, we use cuyo. If we were talking about his voice (voz, which is feminine), it would be cuya voz.

Question 2

Why use the imperfect tenía que instead of the preterite tuvo que?

Accepted Answer

Using the imperfect tenía que describes an ongoing obligation in the background. It sets the scene by telling us what was on his to-do list at the time. If the sentence used the preterite tuvo que, it would focus on the completed event, strongly implying he had to write the song and actually did it.

Question 3

Why is it era obvio instead of estaba obvio?

Accepted Answer

We use era, the imperfect form of ser, because being obvious is treated as a core characteristic of his talent here. The adjective obvio almost always pairs with ser, not estar, because it describes what something is rather than a temporary condition.

Question 4

How do we know the gender of the singer if cantante ends in an 'e'?

Accepted Answer

Words ending in -ante are often gender-neutral. The word itself stays as cantante for both men and women. We know this specific singer is male because of the masculine article el. For a female singer, it would be la cantante.

El cantante, cuyo talento era obvio, tenía que escribir una canción.

Breakdown of El cantante, cuyo talento era obvio, tenía que escribir una canción.

Questions & Answers about El cantante, cuyo talento era obvio, tenía que escribir una canción.

Learn El cantante, cuyo talento era obvio, tenía que escribir una canción and more in Spanish