Breakdown of Preferia que eles não estivessem extintos, mas sim vivos hoje.
não
not / no
sim
yes
eles
they (m)
mas
but
estar
to be (temporary / location)
hoje
today
preferir
to prefer
que
that (conjunction)
vivo
alive
extinto
extinct
Questions & Answers about Preferia que eles não estivessem extintos, mas sim vivos hoje.
Why do we need sim after mas in this sentence?
The structure não... mas sim is used for corrective opposition, meaning "not [this], but rather [that]." It directly corrects the negated state (não estivessem extintos) with the alternative state you want (vivos). If you only used mas, it would feel like you were setting up a contradicting clause rather than offering a direct replacement for the rejected idea.
The provided translation says "I preferred", but with hoje (today), shouldn't it be "I would prefer"?
Exactly. While Preferia literally translates to "I preferred" (imperfect past), Portuguese speakers constantly use the imperfect indicative in place of the conditional tense (Preferiria) to express hypothetical wishes or polite requests. The word hoje makes it completely clear that this is a present contrary-to-fact wish ("I would prefer"), not a past habit.
Why is estivessem in the imperfect subjunctive?
The verb preferir expresses a preference or wish, which triggers the subjunctive mood for the following clause introduced by que. Because the main verb (Preferia) is in a past tense (even though it's acting as a conditional), the rules of tense harmony dictate that the dependent verb must be in the imperfect subjunctive (estivessem).
Extinction is permanent, so why use estar (estivessem) instead of ser (fossem)?
While we think of extinction as a permanent characteristic, Portuguese uses estar here for a couple of reasons. First, extinto is treated as a condition or the resulting state of an event (dying out). Second, it's being directly contrasted with vivos. Because Portuguese uses estar for being alive or dead (estar vivo, estar morto), that same verb governs the contrasting state of being extinct.
Learn Preferia que eles não estivessem extintos, mas sim vivos hoje and more in Portuguese
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free