Question 1

What is the exact difference between desataram a rir and just começaram a rir?

Accepted Answer

While começar a simply means "to start," the structure desatar a followed by an infinitive emphasizes a sudden, explosive, or highly emotional start to an action. It is most commonly used with verbs like laughing, crying, or running, translating perfectly to the English phrase "to burst out."

Question 2

Since the current lesson also covers pôr-se a, could we say eles puseram-se a rir instead?

Accepted Answer

Yes, but there is a slight nuance in feeling. Both desatar a and pôr-se a indicate the sudden initiation of an action. However, desatar a suggests an abrupt loss of restraint, which fits perfectly with the adverb descontroladamente (uncontrollably). Pôr-se a can sometimes feel a little less dramatic or slightly more deliberate.

Question 3

Why do we use the Imperfect tense for era but the Preterite (Pretérito Perfeito) for desataram?

Accepted Answer

This is a classic example of how the two past tenses interact. Era hilariante describes an ongoing characteristic of the joke or sets the background state (Imperfect). In contrast, desataram a rir represents the sudden, completed event that happened at a specific moment as a reaction to that background state (Preterite).

Question 4

I learned that "joke" is piada. Can I use piada instead of anedota here?

Accepted Answer

Yes, they are virtually interchangeable in everyday speech. If there is a distinction, an anedota typically refers to a structured, classic joke with a setup and a punchline (like "two guys walk into a bar"). A piada can be a structured joke too, but it also broadly covers any spontaneous funny remark, quip, or tease.

A anedota era hilariante, por isso eles desataram a rir descontroladamente.

Breakdown of A anedota era hilariante, por isso eles desataram a rir descontroladamente.

Questions & Answers about A anedota era hilariante, por isso eles desataram a rir descontroladamente.

Learn A anedota era hilariante, por isso eles desataram a rir descontroladamente and more in Portuguese