Word
É possível que a chave estivesse oculta no quebra-cabeça.
Meaning
It is possible that the key was hidden in the puzzle.
Part of speech
sentence
Pronunciation
Course
Breakdown of É possível que a chave estivesse oculta no quebra-cabeça.
ser
to be
no
in the, on the, at the
a chave
the key
estar
to be (temporary, location)
Questions & Answers about É possível que a chave estivesse oculta no quebra-cabeça.
Why do we use the past subjunctive estivesse after a present-tense phrase like É possível que?
When you first learn the subjunctive, you usually pair a present-tense trigger with the present subjunctive (É possível que a chave esteja...). However, that only works when both parts of the sentence refer to the present or future. Here, the speaker is talking right now (É possível que) about a situation in the past (a chave estivesse oculta — the key was hidden). When a present-tense trigger looks back at a past state, Portuguese crosses tenses and uses the imperfect subjunctive (estivesse).
Could I use tenha estado instead of estivesse to talk about the past here?
In this sentence, estivesse is the natural choice. A good trick is to think about which tense you would use in a normal, factual past statement: to describe where the key was, you would use the imperfect indicative (A chave estava oculta) because it was an ongoing state in the past. When you put an imperfect indicative idea after a subjunctive trigger like É possível que, it shifts directly to the imperfect subjunctive (estivesse). Tenha estado is rarely used for simple past descriptions like this and would sound unnatural.
How does oculta work here, and how is it different from escondida?