O segredo deste prato não é o queijo, e sim a textura do caldo.

Questions & Answers about O segredo deste prato não é o queijo, e sim a textura do caldo.

Why does this sentence use e sim (literally "and yes") to mean "but instead"?
When you negate one thing to replace it directly with the right one, Brazilian Portuguese pairs não with e sim or mas sim ("not X, but rather Y"). Here, sim acts as an affirmative marker that highlights the correction (a textura do caldo) against what was just rejected (o queijo). Both e sim and mas sim work equally well in this sentence (...não é o queijo, mas sim a textura do caldo). You could also just say mas, though adding sim makes the "not this, but that" contrast much clearer.
Why isn't the verb é repeated after e sim?
When não X, e sim Y contrasts two items that share the same verb, repeating the verb in the second half is unnecessary. Since é is already stated in não é o queijo, e sim connects directly to the replacement noun phrase, a textura do caldo.
Would a Brazilian say deste prato or desse prato here?
You will see and hear both. Deste (the contraction of de + este) is preferred in more formal or careful writing to mean "of this" for something close to the speaker or currently being discussed. In everyday conversation, however, Brazilians very commonly use desse (de + esse) to mean "of this" as well as "of that", so O segredo desse prato is what you will usually hear spoken.
How does caldo differ from molho or sopa?
In a dish like this, o caldo is the liquid broth or stock that forms the base, whereas o molho is a sauce. In Brazil, caldo is also the word for a rich, blended soup served hot in a bowl or mug (such as caldo de feijão or caldo verde), while sopa typically refers to a soup with solid pieces of pasta, vegetables, or meat in it.

Learn O segredo deste prato não é o queijo, e sim a textura do caldo and more in Portuguese

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
  • ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free