Questions & Answers about Você comeu a maçã ou a banana?
Why does comeu end in -eu when the subject is você?
Comeu is the simple past (pretérito perfeito) of the regular -er verb comer (to eat). To form it for você, ele, ela, or a gente, you drop the -er and add -eu. Don't let the spelling trick you: even though the ending looks just like the pronoun eu (I), -eu is the ending for você! For eu, the past ending is -i (eu comi).
Why is there no word for "did" in this question?
Portuguese does not use a helping verb like "did" to form questions in the past. The past meaning is already built into the verb comeu (ate). To turn the statement Você comeu a maçã (You ate the apple) into a question, you keep the same word order and raise the pitch of your voice at the end when speaking, or add a question mark in writing.
How would I answer this question in a conversation?
You can simply name the fruit — for example, A maçã (The apple) — or use the eu form of the verb in the past: Comi a maçã or Eu comi a maçã (I ate the apple). If someone asks a yes-or-no question like Você comeu a maçã? and you want to say "I ate it," Brazilian Portuguese normally just uses the verb by itself without an object pronoun: Comi.
Do I need to repeat a before banana?
How do you pronounce the special letters in maçã?
The ç (cê-cedilha) makes an "s" sound, like in "sun." The ã is a nasal vowel: make an "uh" sound while letting some air pass through your nose. Also, the stress in maçã falls on the last syllable (ma-ÇÃ), because the tilde (~) pulls the stress to that syllable unless the word has another accent mark.
Learn Você comeu a maçã ou a banana and more in Portuguese
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free