Should have and could have (burde ha, skulle ha, kunne ha)

To talk about hindsight, regret or missed possibilities, Norwegian uses the same three-part structure as English: a past-tense modal verb (burde, skulle or kunne), the infinitive ha (have), and a past participle.

StructureMeaningTypical use
burde ha + past participleshould have / ought to haveHindsight advice, what would have been wiser
skulle ha + past participleshould have / was supposed to haveUnfulfilled plans, regret, apologies
kunne ha + past participlecould haveMissed opportunities, near mishaps

Burde ha: hindsight and advice

Use burde ha + past participle to say what would have been the sensible or right thing to do. Regular weak verbs take -et in the participle (laget, varmet, blandet). Si is irregular, so å si fra (to speak up / to notify) becomes sagt fra:

You should have spoken up earlier.
Du burde ha sagt fra tidligere.
We should have made the starter yesterday.
Vi burde ha laget forretten i går.
You should have heated the sauce slowly.
Du burde ha varmet sausen sakte.

To make it negative (should not have), put ikke after the modal verb and before ha (burde ikke ha …):

He should not have mixed the butter into the sauce.
Han burde ikke ha blandet smøret i sausen.

Skulle ha: regret and unfulfilled plans

Both burde ha and skulle ha translate as should have. Skulle ha often points back to an original plan (was supposed to have) or expresses personal regret and self-criticism when something goes wrong.

Some common irregular participles for kitchen tasks:

  • å skjære (to cut / slice) → skåret
  • å brenne (to burn) → brent
  • å legge (to put / lay) → lagt
I should have cut the onion first.
Jeg skulle ha skåret løken først.
I should not have burned the onion in the pot.
Jeg skulle ikke ha brent løken i gryta.

When a sentence starts with an adverbial like egentlig (actually), the modal verb stays in second position and the subject comes right after it, before ha:

Actually, we should have heated the main course earlier.
Egentlig skulle vi ha varmet hovedretten tidligere.

Skulle ikke ha is a natural way to apologize for a mishap. It is often paired with what should have been done instead:

Sorry, I should not have spilled wine on the tablecloth.
Unnskyld, jeg skulle ikke ha sølt vin på duken.
We should have put the other tablecloth on the table.
Vi skulle ha lagt den andre duken på bordet.

Kunne ha: missed possibilities and near mishaps

Use kunne ha + past participle (could have) when someone had the chance to do something but didn't, or when a mishap nearly happened. Note the irregular participle hjulpet (from å hjelpe, to help):

Anna could have mixed the salad for the starter.
Anna kunne ha blandet salaten til forretten.
Per, you could have burned the whole main course in the oven!
Per, du kunne ha brent hele hovedretten i ovnen!
We could have helped each other more in the kitchen.
Vi kunne ha hjulpet hverandre mer på kjøkkenet.

Norwegians often drop ha before the participle (Du burde sagt fra), in speech and also in writing. Both forms are correct. This course keeps ha, which is always clear.