Breakdown of I monaci, i quali seguono una disciplina austera, vivono nel monastero.
una
a / an (feminine)
in
in / made of (material)
seguire
to follow
vivere
to live (life), to be alive
il quale
who, which, whom (also la quale, i quali, le quali)
austero
austere
il monastero
the monastery
il monaco
the monk
la disciplina
the discipline
Questions & Answers about I monaci, i quali seguono una disciplina austera, vivono nel monastero.
Why does this sentence use i quali instead of just che?
In Italian, che is the most common way to say "who" or "that." However, il quale (and its forms like the masculine plural i quali) is a more formal alternative. You will often see it in written Italian or formal speech. Unlike che, it changes to match the gender and number of the noun it refers to (here, the masculine plural i monaci). In this sentence, using che would also be perfectly correct, but i quali slightly elevates the tone.
I thought words ending in -co usually pluralize to -chi. Why is it monaci here?
The plural of words ending in -co generally depends on where the stress falls in the singular word. If the stress is on the second-to-last syllable (like parco), the plural is usually -chi (parchi). But if the stress is on the third-to-last syllable (like mònaco or mèdico), the plural usually softens to -ci (monaci, medici). There are exceptions (like amico becoming amici), but this stress rule is a very reliable guide at the B2 level!
Could we say vivono in monastero instead of nel monastero?
Yes, you could, but the nuance shifts slightly. Saying vivono in monastero focuses abstractly on the lifestyle or the state of being cloistered (similar to the English concept of being "in hospital" or "in prison" without the article). Using nel monastero, as this sentence does, points more tangibly to the physical building or a specific monastery.
Does placing austera after disciplina change the meaning compared to putting it before?
Placing austera after disciplina is the standard, objective way to describe it. It focuses on the literal fact: a strict, rigorous set of rules. If you placed it before the noun (un'austera disciplina), it would sound much more subjective, literary, or poetic. For a straightforward factual description, keeping the adjective after the noun is the most natural choice.
Learn I monaci, i quali seguono una disciplina austera, vivono nel monastero and more in Italian
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free