Breakdown of Ho visto la donna che origliava il nostro discorso.
la donna
the woman
nostro
our
vedere
to see
il discorso
the speech / the talk, conversation
che
who, that (relative pronoun)
origliare
to eavesdrop
Questions & Answers about Ho visto la donna che origliava il nostro discorso.
Why use che origliava instead of an infinitive or an '-ing' word to translate 'eavesdropping'?
With verbs of perception (like vedere or sentire), Italian often uses a 'pseudo-relative' clause: che + the imperfect indicative. This perfectly captures an action in progress, equivalent to the English '-ing' form. While the infinitive (origliare) is also grammatically correct here, using che origliava strongly emphasizes the ongoing, continuous nature of the eavesdropping at the exact moment she was seen.
Could I use the gerund origliando here, since it literally translates to 'eavesdropping'?
No, and this is a classic trap! In Italian, the gerund almost always refers back to the subject of the main verb. If you said Ho visto la donna origliando, it would actually mean 'I saw the woman while I was eavesdropping.' To describe the object's action, you must use the che + imperfect structure or the infinitive.
Doesn't la donna che origliava just mean 'the woman who was eavesdropping'? How is this different from a normal relative clause?
Grammatically, it looks identical to a standard relative clause. However, in this specific context (perception verb + object + che), it functions as a pseudo-relative clause. The difference is the focus: a normal relative clause identifies the noun ('I saw the woman—the one who was eavesdropping'), while a pseudo-relative clause focuses on perceiving the action itself ('I saw her in the act of eavesdropping'). Context makes the intended meaning clear.
If I wanted to replace la donna with a pronoun ('I saw her eavesdropping'), how would the sentence change?
The direct object pronoun goes before the main conjugated verb. You would say L'ho vista che origliava il nostro discorso. Notice that because you are using a third-person direct object pronoun (la) with the passato prossimo, the past participle must agree with it, changing from visto to vista.
Learn Ho visto la donna che origliava il nostro discorso and more in Italian
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free