Breakdown of Det är stolen som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor på.
Questions & Answers about Det är stolen som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor på.
Det är … som … is a very common cleft construction in Swedish, used to emphasize a particular part of the sentence.
Basic sentence: Gästerna lägger alltid sina väskor på stolen.
= The guests always put their bags on the chair.Cleft (emphasizing the chair): Det är stolen som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor på.
= It is the chair that the guests always put their bags on.
Det here is a “dummy” pronoun (like English it in It is John who…). You can’t drop it — just saying Stolen som gästerna… would be ungrammatical as a main clause. The pattern is:
Det är + [focused element] + som + [rest of clause]
Som is a relative pronoun here, introducing a relative clause that describes stolen:
- stolen = the chair
- som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor på = that the guests always put their bags on
So som here corresponds roughly to English that or which:
- It is the chair *that the guests always put their bags on.*
In Swedish:
- som is used for both people and things (unlike English who/that/which).
- In this cleft structure Det är X som …, you basically always use som.
Swedish usually marks definiteness with an ending on the noun:
- stol = chair (indefinite, “a chair”)
- stolen = the chair (definite, “the chair”)
Here, you are talking about a specific, known chair — the one that the guests always use for their bags. So Swedish requires the definite form stolen.
Compare:
Det är en stol som gästerna lägger sina väskor på.
= It is a chair that the guests put their bags on. (some unspecified chair)Det är stolen som gästerna lägger sina väskor på.
= It is the chair that the guests put their bags on. (a particular one we both know about)
You can’t say stolen på som… — that’s wrong word order.
Swedish allows preposition stranding in relative clauses, similar to spoken English:
- English: It’s the chair that the guests put their bags *on.*
- Swedish: Det är stolen som gästerna lägger sina väskor på.
So in the relative clause som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor på, på stays with the verb phrase lägger … på, not directly after stolen.
You could also front the preposition, but then you’d typically move the prepositional phrase as a whole:
- Det är på stolen som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor.
= It is on the chair that the guests always put their bags.
Both are correct; the original version focuses on stolen (the chair itself), the second one focuses more on på stolen (the location).
That sounds wrong in standard Swedish. You don’t use där in this cleft construction the way you might use where in English.
- Incorrect: Det är på stolen där gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor.
- Correct options:
- Det är stolen som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor på.
- Det är på stolen som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor.
Där means “there/where” and can introduce a kind of relative clause, but not in this structure. Here, Swedish strongly prefers som as the relative marker.
- gäster = guests (indefinite plural, “(some) guests”)
- gästerna = the guests (definite plural, “the guests”)
In this sentence, you’re referring to a known group of guests in a particular context (for example, guests in your house, in your hotel, etc.), so Swedish uses the definite form:
- gästerna = those particular guests we’re talking about
If you said:
- Det är stolen som gäster alltid lägger sina väskor på.
it would sound like “It is the chair that guests (in general, any guests) always put their bags on,” which is possible but feels more generic and less natural in many contexts than gästerna.
Swedish has different verbs for “put” depending on the final position of the object:
- lägga (lägger, lade, lagt) – to lay, put something in a lying/horizontal position
- ställa (ställer, ställde, ställt) – to put/place something in a standing/vertical position
- sätta (sätter, satte, satt) – to set, often for sitting things or placing in a more fixed way
Bags are usually thought of as being put down in a more “lying” way, so lägga is natural:
- Gästerna lägger sina väskor på stolen.
= The guests put (lay) their bags on the chair.
You might use ställa for e.g. bottles, vases, or other things that stand upright:
- Han ställer flaskan på bordet.
= He puts/stands the bottle on the table.
This is about the difference between sina (reflexive) and deras (non‑reflexive) possessive pronouns.
- sina refers back to the subject of the same clause.
- deras refers to someone else’s things.
In the clause som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor på:
- Subject = gästerna
- Possessive = sina (bags belonging to the same guests)
So sina väskor means “their own bags” (the guests’ bags).
If you said deras väskor here, it would usually mean that the guests put someone else’s bags on the chair, not their own. That would change the meaning.
Sin/sitt/sina all mean “one’s own / his own / her own / their own,” but they agree with the noun they describe, not with the owner.
- sin – with an en‑word in singular
- sitt – with an ett‑word in singular
- sina – with any plural noun
Here, väskor is plural:
- en väska → väskor
- plural → so you must use sina
Examples:
- Gästerna lägger sin väska på stolen. (one bag each)
- Gästerna lägger sina väskor på stolen. (multiple bags)
Yes, that’s a perfectly correct and very natural sentence:
- Gästerna lägger alltid sina väskor på stolen.
= The guests always put their bags on the chair.
The difference is mainly focus:
Gästerna lägger alltid sina väskor på stolen.
– a neutral statement about what the guests do.Det är stolen som gästerna alltid lägger sina väskor på.
– emphasizes stolen:
“It’s that chair (not some other place) that the guests always put their bags on.”
So you use the cleft form when you want to highlight or contrast a specific part (here, the chair).
In Swedish, the definite article is normally attached as an ending to the noun:
- stol → stolen
- bok → boken
- rum → rummet
You only add a separate article (den, det, de) before the noun in certain cases, for example when the noun has an adjective:
- den stora stolen = the big chair
- den här stolen = this chair
But with a simple, bare noun like here, you just use the suffixed form:
- stolen = the chair (no extra den needed)