Breakdown of A sala de ciências cuja porta estava fechada abre às oito.
Questions & Answers about A sala de ciências cuja porta estava fechada abre às oito.
What does cuja mean in this sentence?
Why is it cuja and not cujo?
Does cuja refer to sala or porta?
Why is there no article after cuja? Why not cuja a porta?
Can I replace cuja with que?
Not directly.
This is correct:
But this is not correct:
- A sala de ciências que a porta estava fechada...
The problem is that que by itself does not show possession.
If you want to avoid cuja, you usually need to rephrase. For example:
- A sala de ciências com a porta fechada...
- A sala de ciências que estava com a porta fechada...
In everyday Brazilian Portuguese, people often avoid cujo/cuja and use a different structure like that.
Is cuja common in Brazilian Portuguese?
It is common in:
- writing
- formal speech
- school grammar
- news or academic style
But in casual spoken Brazilian Portuguese, many people avoid it and use simpler alternatives.
So the sentence is perfectly correct, but it sounds somewhat more formal or written than everyday conversation.
Why is it porta estava fechada? Why is fechada feminine?
Why is estava in the past, but abre in the present?
Because the sentence is combining two different time ideas:
- estava fechada describes a past state of the door
- abre às oito gives the room’s present or usual opening time
That kind of tense mix is possible if the speaker has a reason to mention a past detail about the room while stating a current schedule.
So the structure is grammatical, even though it may feel a little unusual without wider context.
If everything were in the present, you might say:
If everything were in the past, you might say:
- A sala de ciências cuja porta estava fechada abria às oito.
What is the difference between abre às oito and está aberta às oito?
They are not the same.
- abre às oito = it opens at eight
- está aberta às oito = it is open at eight
So abre às oito focuses on the moment the room opens.
Example:
- A loja abre às oito. = The store opens at eight.
- A loja está aberta às oito. = The store is open at eight.
In your sentence, abre às oito means eight is the opening time.
Why is it às oito with a grave accent?
Because às is a contraction of:
- a
- as
In time expressions, Portuguese normally uses this contraction:
- à uma
- às duas
- às oito
So:
- abre às oito = opens at eight
The grave accent marks crase, the merger of those two vowels.
What does sala de ciências mean exactly, and why is ciências plural?
Would commas change the meaning here?
Yes.
Without commas:
This is restrictive. It identifies which science room you mean: the one whose door was closed.
With commas:
- A sala de ciências, cuja porta estava fechada, abre às oito.
This is non-restrictive. It sounds like the speaker already knows which science room is being discussed, and cuja porta estava fechada is just extra information about it.
So the commas change the function of the relative clause.
Is cuja only used for people, like English whose?
No. In Portuguese, cujo/cuja can refer to people, animals, things, places, institutions, and so on.
So it is completely normal to say:
- a casa cuja janela quebrou
- o livro cujo autor ganhou o prêmio
- a sala cuja porta estava fechada
English learners sometimes think whose is mainly for people, but Portuguese cujo is very comfortable with non-human nouns too.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PortugueseMaster Portuguese — from A sala de ciências cuja porta estava fechada abre às oito to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions