Magistra dicit bonum participem disputationis non solum audire, sed etiam aperte respondere.

Questions & Answers about Magistra dicit bonum participem disputationis non solum audire, sed etiam aperte respondere.

Why is participem used instead of particeps?

Particeps is the dictionary form, or nominative singular. In this sentence, the word is not the subject of the infinitives; it is the person being described in the statement after dicit. Because of that, Latin puts it in the accusative: participem.

This happens because Latin often uses an accusative + infinitive construction after verbs like dicit (says).

So:

  • particeps = nominative, a participant
  • participem = accusative, a participant as the object/form used in indirect statement

Why is it bonum participem and not bonus particeps?

For the same reason: both words are in the accusative singular.

  • bonus particeps would be nominative singular: a good participant as a subject
  • bonum participem is accusative singular: a good participant inside the indirect statement

The adjective must agree with the noun it describes in case, number, and gender.

So:

  • bonum agrees with participem
  • both are accusative singular masculine/feminine here

Why are audire and respondere infinitives?

Because after dicit, Latin is using indirect statement.

English often says:

  • The teacher says that a good participant ... listens and responds.

Latin typically does this differently:

  • Magistra dicit
    • accusative subject
      • infinitive verb(s)

So:

  • bonum participem = the subject of the reported statement, in the accusative
  • audire and respondere = infinitives expressing what that participant does

This is a very common Latin pattern, often called the accusative and infinitive construction.


Where is the word for that?

There is no separate word for that here, because Latin usually does not need one in this kind of sentence.

English says:

  • The teacher says that ...

Latin often says:

  • The teacher says ...
    • accusative + infinitive

So the idea of that is built into the structure itself.

In other words:

  • Magistra dicit = The teacher says
  • bonum participem ... audire ... respondere = that a good participant listens ... and responds ...

What is disputationis doing here?

Disputationis is a genitive singular form, meaning of the discussion or of the debate.

It depends on participem:

  • particeps disputationis = participant in / of the discussion

Latin often uses the genitive where English might prefer:

  • participant in the discussion
  • participant of the discussion (less natural in English, but closer to the Latin structure)

So disputationis tells us what the person is participating in.


How does non solum ... sed etiam ... work?

This is a very common pairing meaning:

  • not only ... but also ...

Here it links two infinitives:

  • non solum audire
  • sed etiam aperte respondere

So the structure is:

  • not only to listen
  • but also to respond openly

It is important that the two parts are parallel. Both audire and respondere depend on the same idea and match each other grammatically.


What does aperte mean, and what kind of word is it?

Aperte is an adverb. It means something like:

  • openly
  • clearly
  • frankly

It modifies respondere:

  • aperte respondere = to respond openly / clearly

A learner might notice that aperte looks related to apertus (open). That is correct: it is the adverb form.


Does particeps here mean participle?

No. Even though the words look similar in English, particeps here means participant or one who takes part.

So:

  • particeps = participant
  • participle in grammar = a completely different idea

This is an easy thing for English speakers to misread at first.


Why is the word order different from English?

Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order because Latin shows grammatical relationships through endings, not mainly through position.

So although the sentence begins:

  • Magistra dicit ...

the rest can be arranged in different ways without changing the core meaning.

This order puts:

  • bonum participem disputationis together as a unit
  • then the paired infinitives:
    • non solum audire
    • sed etiam aperte respondere

The order is quite natural and makes the contrast clear.


Is magistra definitely the subject?

Yes. Magistra is in the nominative singular, so it is the subject of dicit.

So:

  • Magistra = the teacher
  • dicit = says

Together:

  • Magistra dicit = The teacher says

By contrast, bonum participem is accusative, so it is not the main subject of dicit; it is the subject of the infinitives inside the indirect statement.


Could audire and respondere be translated with should in English?

Yes, depending on context, English might naturally use should:

  • The teacher says that a good participant should not only listen, but also respond openly.

Strictly speaking, the Latin sentence itself does not contain a separate word meaning should. The infinitives simply express what the teacher says a good participant does. But in English, when someone is stating a general principle, adding should can sound more natural.

So both of these may work in translation, depending on tone:

  • The teacher says that a good participant not only listens, but also responds openly.
  • The teacher says that a good participant should not only listen, but also respond openly.
AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
What's the best way to learn Latin grammar?
Latin grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Latin

Master Latin — from Magistra dicit bonum participem disputationis non solum audire, sed etiam aperte respondere to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • AI tutor to answer your grammar questions