Breakdown of Discipula a magistra laudari vult, quia diligenter laborat.
Questions & Answers about Discipula a magistra laudari vult, quia diligenter laborat.
Why is discipula in the nominative case?
Because discipula is the subject of the main verb vult (wants).
So the basic structure is:
- Discipula ... vult = The schoolgirl wants ...
Even though laudari is passive (to be praised), the person who wants something is still the subject of vult, so Latin uses the nominative discipula.
Why is magistra changed to a magistra?
Because laudari is a passive infinitive (to be praised), and Latin often marks the personal agent of a passive verb with a/ab + ablative.
So:
- a magistra = by the teacher
This is the same pattern you see with normal passive verbs:
- Discipula a magistra laudatur = The schoolgirl is praised by the teacher
Here, the same idea appears inside an infinitive phrase:
- a magistra laudari = to be praised by the teacher
Why is it laudari and not laudare?
Because laudari is the present passive infinitive, while laudare is the present active infinitive.
- laudare = to praise
- laudari = to be praised
Since the meaning is that the schoolgirl wants to be praised, Latin uses the passive infinitive laudari.
Compare:
- Discipula magistram laudare vult = The schoolgirl wants to praise the teacher
- Discipula a magistra laudari vult = The schoolgirl wants to be praised by the teacher
How does vult work with laudari?
Vult means she wants, and it can take an infinitive to express wants to ...
So:
- vult laudari = wants to be praised
This is very similar to English:
- She wants to be praised
In Latin, this is a very common construction:
- a finite verb of wanting, being able, beginning, etc.
- plus an infinitive
How do I know who is doing the praising and who is receiving it?
The grammar tells you.
- discipula is the one who wants
- laudari is passive, so the subject of the main clause is understood as the one being praised
- a magistra gives the agent, the person doing the praising
So:
- the teacher does the praising
- the schoolgirl receives the praising
That is why the sentence means:
- The schoolgirl wants to be praised by the teacher...
Why is magistra in the ablative?
Because after a/ab meaning by with a passive verb, Latin uses the ablative case.
So:
- magistra by itself could be nominative or ablative depending on context
- here, because it follows a, it is clearly ablative: a magistra = by the teacher
This is the normal way Latin expresses a personal agent with a passive.
Why is it a and not ab?
Both a and ab mean from or by, and both can be used before the ablative.
A simple rule learners are often given is:
- ab before vowels or sometimes for clarity/emphasis
- a often before consonants
Since magistra begins with a consonant sound, a magistra is the expected form.
What does quia do in the sentence?
Quia means because and introduces a reason.
So the sentence has two parts:
- Discipula a magistra laudari vult
- quia diligenter laborat
Together:
- The schoolgirl wants to be praised by the teacher, because she works diligently.
The quia clause explains why she wants or deserves praise.
Who is the subject of laborat?
The subject is understood to be the same person, the schoolgirl.
- laborat = she works
Latin often leaves subject pronouns unstated because the verb ending already shows the person and number.
Here laborat is third person singular, so it means:
- he/she/it works
From the context, it clearly refers to discipula.
What does diligenter mean, and what kind of word is it?
Diligenter means diligently or carefully, and it is an adverb.
It modifies laborat:
- laborat = works
- diligenter laborat = works diligently
A common pattern in Latin is that many adverbs end in -ter, though not all do.
Is the word order unusual? Why isn’t it in a more English-like order?
Latin word order is much freer than English word order because the endings show grammatical relationships.
A more English-like arrangement might be:
- Discipula vult a magistra laudari, quia diligenter laborat.
But Latin can also say:
- Discipula a magistra laudari vult, quia diligenter laborat.
Both are natural. The infinitive laudari is often placed near vult, but other orders are possible too.
In Latin, you should rely more on:
- case endings
- verb forms
- prepositions
than on word order alone.
Could Latin have used an active construction instead of the passive one?
Yes, but it would mean something different.
This sentence says:
- Discipula a magistra laudari vult = The schoolgirl wants to be praised by the teacher
If you changed it to an active infinitive, you would get:
- Discipula magistram laudare vult = The schoolgirl wants to praise the teacher
So the passive is essential here, because the schoolgirl is the one receiving the praise, not giving it.
Why is there no separate Latin word for she before vult or laborat?
Because Latin verb endings already include the subject information.
- vult = he/she/it wants
- laborat = he/she/it works
Since discipula is already present, Latin does not need to add ea (she). In fact, adding the pronoun would often be unnecessary unless there were special emphasis or contrast.
So Latin naturally says:
- Discipula ... vult
- not usually Discipula ea ... vult
Is laudari present in time? Does it mean she wants to be praised right now?
Not exactly. In Latin, the present infinitive usually shows aspect more than strict time. With vult, laudari means to be praised, without necessarily emphasizing whether the action is happening at this exact moment.
So vult laudari means:
- she wants to be praised
- or she wants the teacher to praise her
It is the normal infinitive form to use here.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Discipula a magistra laudari vult, quia diligenter laborat to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions