Breakdown of Hodie comitia in foro habentur, et multi cives de uno candidato inter se disputant.
Questions & Answers about Hodie comitia in foro habentur, et multi cives de uno candidato inter se disputant.
Why is comitia plural, even if English might translate it as the election or the assembly?
Comitia is a Latin noun that is normally plural in form. It refers to a public assembly, especially a political or voting assembly of Roman citizens.
So even when English uses a singular expression like the election or the assembly, Latin often uses comitia as a neuter plural noun.
- nominative plural: comitia
- verb with it: habentur = are held
This is similar to how some English nouns are grammatically plural even when they refer to one event or institution.
Why is the verb habentur and not habent?
Habentur is passive, from habeo, habere.
Here, comitia habentur means the elections/assembly are being held.
This is an idiomatic Latin way to talk about public events:
- ludi habentur = games are being held
- comitia habentur = elections/assemblies are being held
So although habeo often means have or hold, the passive is very natural here when the event itself is the subject.
What tense is habentur, and how should I understand it?
Habentur is present tense, passive, third person plural.
Breaking it down:
- present = happening now
- passive = the subject receives the action
- third person plural = they are held
So Hodie comitia in foro habentur means something like:
- Today the elections are being held in the forum
- or more simply, Today there is an election in the forum
Why is it in foro and not in forum?
Because in takes different cases depending on meaning.
- in + ablative = in/on a place, showing location
- in + accusative = into/onto a place, showing motion toward
Here there is no movement; the elections are happening in the forum, so Latin uses the ablative:
- forum = nominative/accusative singular
- foro = ablative singular
So:
- in foro = in the forum
- but in forum would mean into the forum
Why is multi cives nominative, not accusative?
Because multi cives is the subject of disputant.
The second clause is: et multi cives de uno candidato inter se disputant
The people doing the action are many citizens, so they must be in the nominative case.
- multi = nominative plural masculine
- cives = nominative plural of civis
If they were the direct object, you would expect the accusative:
- multos cives
But here they are the ones arguing/discussing, so multi cives is correct.
Why is candidato in the ablative?
Because it follows the preposition de, and de takes the ablative.
- de uno candidato = about one candidate
This is a very common pattern in Latin:
- de re = about the matter
- de amico = about the friend
- de bello = about the war
So candidato is ablative singular because de requires it.
What exactly does uno mean here?
Uno is the ablative singular of unus, meaning one.
Since it agrees with candidato, it is also:
- masculine
- singular
- ablative
So de uno candidato literally means about one candidate.
Depending on context, one here can mean:
- a single candidate
- one particular candidate
It does not necessarily stress the number strongly in English; sometimes it simply helps identify that the discussion is about a certain individual.
What does inter se mean?
Inter se is an idiomatic Latin expression meaning:
- with one another
- among themselves
- with each other
It is made of:
- inter = among, between
- se = themselves
So multi cives ... inter se disputant means that the citizens are debating with each other, not speaking to some outside person.
Why is it disputant de? Does disputare mean the same thing as English dispute?
Not exactly.
Latin disputare often means:
- to discuss
- to debate
- to argue about
So de uno candidato disputant means the citizens are discussing or debating that candidate.
The English word dispute often sounds more confrontational, but Latin disputare can be more neutral. It does not always imply a hostile quarrel.
Why doesn’t Latin use words for the or a in this sentence?
Because Classical Latin has no articles.
There is no separate word for:
- the
- a/an
So Latin simply says:
- in foro
- multi cives
- de uno candidato
English must supply the article based on context:
- in the forum
- many citizens
- about a/one candidate
This is something English speakers often have to get used to when reading Latin.
Is the word order unusual? Why isn’t it arranged more like English?
Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order because Latin uses case endings to show grammatical roles.
English depends heavily on word order:
- subject + verb + object
Latin can move words around more freely for emphasis, style, or rhythm.
In this sentence:
- Hodie comes first to emphasize time: today
- comitia appears early as the main topic
- in foro is placed before the verb
- inter se is inserted before disputant
Even though the order is different from normal English, the endings make the structure clear.
How do I know that cives is from civis, and what declension is it?
Civis is a third-declension noun meaning citizen.
Its nominative singular is:
- civis
Its nominative plural is:
- cives
So multi cives means many citizens.
This is a good noun to memorize because it is very common in political and historical Latin.
Why are there two present-tense verbs in the sentence: habentur and disputant?
Because the sentence has two coordinated clauses joined by et:
- Hodie comitia in foro habentur
- et multi cives de uno candidato inter se disputant
Each clause has its own verb:
- habentur = are being held
- disputant = discuss/argue
So the sentence is basically:
- Today the elections are being held in the forum, and many citizens are debating with each other about one candidate.
What is the function of hodie in the sentence?
Hodie is an adverb meaning today.
It modifies the whole first clause by giving the time of the action:
- Hodie comitia in foro habentur = Today the elections are being held in the forum
Because it stands first, it also gives a slight emphasis to the time setting. Latin often places an important adverb early in the sentence.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Hodie comitia in foro habentur, et multi cives de uno candidato inter se disputant to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions