Breakdown of Pater rogat: "Cur domi manes et cum amicis non curris?"
Questions & Answers about Pater rogat: "Cur domi manes et cum amicis non curris?"
Pater is the nominative singular of pater, patris – father as the subject of the verb.
Rogat is he/she/it asks (3rd person singular, present indicative, from rogare).
Latin usually does not use a separate subject pronoun (like he) when the verb ending already shows the person.
So:
- pater rogat = father asks or the father asks
- The -t ending on rogat tells you the subject is he / she / it.
Domi is the locative case of domus (house, home). The locative is a special case used mainly for:
- Names of cities and small islands (e.g. Romae = in/at Rome)
- A few special nouns such as domus (home), rūs (the countryside)
So:
- domi = at home (locative)
- in domo = in the house or inside the house (ablative with a preposition)
In this sentence, domi manes means you stay at home, not just physically inside a house building.
Both verbs are present indicative, 2nd person singular:
manes – from manēre (to stay, remain)
- Present stem: manē-
- Ending -s → you stay / you are staying
curris – from currere (to run)
- Present stem: curr-
- Ending -is → you run / you are running
In Latin, the ending tells you the subject:
- man-es → you stay
- curr-is → you run
So there is no need to say tu (you). It is understood from -es and -is.
Latin regularly drops subject pronouns because the verb ending already indicates the person:
- manes and curris both have 2nd person singular endings.
- So the meaning you (singular) stay and you (singular) run is built into the verb forms.
You can add tu for emphasis:
- Cur tu domi manes et cum amicis non curris?
This would stress you in contrast to someone else (e.g. Why do *you stay at home…?*).
Amicis is ablative plural of amicus, amici (friend).
With cum, the ablative is used to express accompaniment:
- cum amicis = with (your) friends
So:
- cum
- ablative → with someone
- amicis is in the ablative to show that the action curris (you run) happens together with friends.
Yes, with nouns like amicis, Latin normally puts cum before:
- cum amicis (most common order)
But Latin also allows postposition with cum, especially with pronouns:
- mecum = with me (not cum me)
- tecum = with you
- nobiscum, vobiscum, secum
With regular nouns, amicis cum can occur in poetry or for stylistic reasons, but in ordinary prose cum amicis is standard and natural.
Cur means why and is a question word, so it naturally goes to the front of its clause:
- Cur domi manes ... ? → Why do you stay at home … ?
Unlike English, Latin does not need special word order changes like:
- English: You stay at home. → Why *do you stay at home?*
- Latin: Manes domi. → Cur domi manes?
Latin forms questions by:
- Using question words (cur, quid, quis, etc.), or
- Adding -ne to a word (e.g. manesne?) for a yes/no question,
but it does not rely on auxiliary verbs or inversion the way English does. Word order is more flexible.
Non usually comes immediately before the word it negates, most often the verb:
- non curris = you do not run
In this sentence, the father is contrasting two actions:
- domi manes – you stay at home
- cum amicis non curris – (and) you do not run with (your) friends
So non is put right before curris to negate that particular action.
You could say cur non curris cum amicis? in another context, but here the rhythm and contrast of manes … non curris is clear and natural.
You can reverse them:
- Cur cum amicis non curris et domi manes?
The basic meaning stays the same: Why do you not run with your friends and stay at home?
However, in Latin (as in English) earlier elements are often more prominent. The original order:
- Cur domi manes et cum amicis non curris?
starts with the unexpected behavior: staying at home, and then adds the contrast: not running with friends.
If you reverse them, the emphasis slightly shifts to not running with friends as the first focus.
The text uses direct speech:
- Pater rogat: Cur domi manes…?
Father asks: Why do you stay at home … ?
Latin also has indirect questions, which use the subjunctive:
- Pater rogat cur domi maneas et cum amicis non curras.
Father asks why you stay at home and do not run with your friends.
Difference:
- Direct speech: repeats the exact words of the speaker; keeps indicative for real questions.
- Indirect question: reports the question as content; uses the subjunctive (here maneas, curras).
The example sentence is simply showing you what the father actually says.
Domi comes from domus, domus (sometimes domus, -i), which is feminine.
Dictionary form: domus, -us (f.)
Important points:
- It is one of the few common nouns that have a locative: domi = at home.
- Because it’s a special word with its own locative form, Latin prefers domi rather than in domo when the meaning is “at home” in a general sense.
You would change the verbs to 2nd person plural:
- manes → manetis (you all stay)
- curris → curritis (you all run)
So the sentence becomes:
- Pater rogat: Cur domi manetis et cum amicis non curritis?
Father asks: Why do you (plural) stay at home and not run with your friends?
The noun amicis is already ablative plural, so it does not need to change.