kono mise no keeki ha ninki ga takakute, mettani tokubai ni naranai.

Questions & Answers about kono mise no keeki ha ninki ga takakute, mettani tokubai ni naranai.

Why is it この店のケーキ and not just このケーキ?

この店のケーキ means the cakes of this shop / this shop’s cakes.

  • この = this
  • = shop/store
  • = links nouns, similar to of or an apostrophe-s
  • ケーキ = cake / cakes

So この店のケーキ means the cakes sold by this shop.

If you said このケーキ, that would mean this cake, referring to one particular cake near the speaker.


Why is there after ケーキ?

The marks この店のケーキ as the topic of the sentence.

So the sentence is saying, roughly:

  • As for this shop’s cakes, their popularity is high, and they rarely go on sale.

This is very common in Japanese:

  • A は B が ...
  • As for A, B is ...

Here:

  • この店のケーキ は = as for this shop’s cakes
  • 人気 が 高くて = their popularity is high

Why is it 人気が高い? Why not 人気がある?

Both 人気が高い and 人気がある are natural and mean something like to be popular.

The difference is mostly nuance:

  • 人気がある = there is popularity; a very common, straightforward way to say is popular
  • 人気が高い = the level of popularity is high; slightly more descriptive or evaluative

In this sentence, 人気が高い emphasizes that the cakes are very popular / highly popular.


Why is the particle used with 人気?

In 人気が高い, 人気 is the thing being described as high.

So:

  • 人気 = popularity
  • marks it as the subject of the adjective
  • 高い = high

Literally, it is like saying:

  • popularity is high

This is why Japanese often uses patterns like:

  • 値段が高い = the price is high
  • 身長が高い = the height is high / someone is tall
  • 人気が高い = popularity is high

What does 高くて mean here?

高くて is the -て form of 高い.

Here it connects two related ideas:

  • 人気が高くて
  • めったに特売にならない

So it means something like:

  • because they are popular, they rarely go on sale or
  • they are popular, and as a result they rarely go on sale

The -て form often connects clauses and can imply:

  • simple sequence
  • two related descriptions
  • cause/reason

In this sentence, a reason-like connection is very natural.


Could this sentence use 人気で instead of 人気が高くて?

Yes, 人気で、めったに特売にならない is also possible.

That version treats 人気 more directly as the reason:

  • because they’re popular, they rarely go on sale

The original 人気が高くて is a bit fuller and more descriptive:

  • their popularity is high, so...

Both are natural, but the original highlights the degree of popularity more clearly.


Why is めったに used with a negative verb?

めったに almost always goes with a negative form and means:

  • rarely
  • seldom
  • hardly ever

So:

  • めったに~ない = rarely do ~

Examples:

  • めったに行かない = I rarely go
  • めったに見ない = I rarely see
  • めったに特売にならない = it rarely goes on sale

Using めったに without a negative verb is generally incorrect in standard Japanese.


What does 特売になる mean exactly?

特売 means special sale, sale price, or special bargain sale.

~になる means to become ~.

So:

  • 特売になる = to become a sale item, to go on special, to be put on sale

In this sentence:

  • めったに特売にならない = they rarely go on sale

It does not mean the cakes become cheap by themselves; it means the store rarely sells them at a special discount price.


Why is the particle used in 特売になる?

The particle is often used with なる to mark the result of a change.

Pattern:

Examples:

  • 先生になる = become a teacher
  • 春になる = become spring / it becomes spring
  • 有名になる = become famous
  • 特売になる = become a sale item / go on sale

So 特売に is the state/result, and ならない means does not become.


Why is it ならない and not ない?

Because the verb is なる (to become), not a simple adjective or noun sentence.

The structure is:

  • 特売になる = to go on sale
  • negative: 特売にならない = does not go on sale

You cannot say 特売ない here because 特売 is a noun, and the grammar needed is noun + に + なる.


Is ケーキ singular or plural here?

It can be understood as cake or cakes, depending on context.

Japanese nouns usually do not show singular/plural the way English nouns do. So:

  • この店のケーキ can mean
    • this shop’s cake
    • this shop’s cakes

In this sentence, English will often translate it as this shop’s cakes because the statement is general:

  • they are popular
  • they rarely go on sale

Does この店のケーキは人気が高くて sound like “the cakes are popular,” or “the popularity of the cakes is high”?

Grammatically, it is closer to:

  • the popularity of this shop’s cakes is high

But in natural English, we usually say:

  • this shop’s cakes are very popular

Japanese often expresses things through nouns like 人気 rather than always using a direct adjective equivalent.

So the literal structure and the natural translation are slightly different.


What is the overall sentence structure?

It breaks down like this:

  • この店のケーキは = as for this shop’s cakes
  • 人気が高くて、 = their popularity is high / they are very popular, and so...
  • めったに = rarely
  • 特売に = into a sale item / on special
  • ならない = do not become

So the whole sentence is built as:

  • Topic + description/reason + negative result

A very literal gloss would be:

  • As for this shop’s cakes, their popularity is high, so they rarely become sale items.

Natural English:

  • This shop’s cakes are very popular, so they rarely go on sale.

Is there any nuance behind saying they rarely go on sale?

Yes. The sentence suggests a reason-and-result relationship:

  • the cakes are popular
  • because demand is high, the store usually does not need to discount them

So it implies:

  • they sell well anyway
  • the shop has little reason to lower the price

That nuance comes from 人気が高くて connecting naturally to めったに特売にならない.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
How do verb conjugations work in Japanese?
Japanese verbs conjugate based on tense, politeness, and mood. For example, the polite present form adds ‑ます to the verb stem, while the past tense uses ‑ました. Unlike English, Japanese verbs don't change based on the subject — the same form works for "I", "you", and "they".

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Japanese

Master Japanese — from kono mise no keeki ha ninki ga takakute, mettani tokubai ni naranai to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • AI tutor to answer your grammar questions