Breakdown of ane ha oozei no mae de utauno wo hazukasigaru keredo, hitori de ha yoku utatte iru.
Questions & Answers about ane ha oozei no mae de utauno wo hazukasigaru keredo, hitori de ha yoku utatte iru.
Why is there a は after 姉?
姉は marks older sister as the topic of the sentence.
So the sentence is talking about the older sister, and everything after that describes her behavior.
- 姉は = As for my older sister...
- It does not necessarily mean she is the grammatical subject in the same way as English; it marks what the sentence is about.
Also, in Japanese, 姉 usually means my older sister when speaking to someone outside the family.
What does 大勢の前で mean exactly?
大勢 means a large number of people / many people.
前 means front, and 〜の前で means in front of ~.
So:
- 大勢の前で = in front of many people
- more literally: before a large crowd
The particle で marks the setting or situation where the action happens.
Why is it 歌うのを and not just 歌うを?
Because 歌う is a verb, and Japanese usually cannot attach を directly to a plain verb that way. The verb has to be turned into a noun-like phrase first.
That is what の is doing here.
- 歌う = to sing
- 歌うの = singing / the act of singing
- 歌うのを = marks singing as the thing connected to the next verb
So 歌うのを恥ずかしがる means something like:
- to be shy/embarrassed about singing
- literally, to feel embarrassed about the act of singing
Could こと be used instead of の in 歌うのを?
Yes, 歌うことを is grammatically possible in many cases, but 歌うのを sounds more natural here.
A useful guideline:
- の often feels more direct, concrete, or tied to an actual action
- こと can sound more abstract or formal
Since this sentence is about the very real activity of singing in front of people, 歌うのを恥ずかしがる is a natural choice.
What is the difference between 恥ずかしい and 恥ずかしがる?
This is an important point.
- 恥ずかしい = to feel embarrassed / ashamed
- 恥ずかしがる = to show embarrassment / to act shy / to be shy about something
Why use 恥ずかしがる here?
In Japanese, when talking about another person's internal feelings, it is often more natural to use a form like 〜がる, which describes the way they appear or behave, rather than directly stating their feelings.
So:
- 姉は歌うのを恥ずかしがる = My older sister is shy about singing
- It focuses on her observable behavior or tendency
This is more natural than directly saying 姉は恥ずかしい in this context.
Why is there a を after 歌うの if 恥ずかしがる does not mean “do singing”?
Because を here marks the thing that she feels shy or embarrassed about.
In Japanese, some emotional or attitude-related expressions can take an object-like phrase with を.
So in:
- 歌うのを恥ずかしがる
the meaning is:
- to be shy about singing
- to feel embarrassed about singing
It is not that she does the singing as the object of 恥ずかしがる. Rather, singing is the thing that triggers the embarrassed feeling.
What does けれど do here?
けれど means but / although / however.
It connects two contrasting ideas:
- she is shy about singing in front of many people,
- but she sings a lot when she is alone.
So it shows a contrast between:
- public singing → shy
- singing alone → does it often
In conversation, けれど often sounds a little softer than a blunt but in English.
Why does the sentence say 一人では instead of just 一人で?
Because the は adds contrast.
- 一人で = alone / by herself
- 一人では = when she is alone, on the other hand...
So the sentence contrasts two situations:
- 大勢の前で = in front of many people
- 一人では = when alone, by contrast
This は is not the main topic marker here. It is a contrastive は.
What does よく mean here?
Here, よく means often.
So:
- よく歌っている = she often sings
Be careful: よく can also mean well, depending on context.
For example:
- よく歌う = sing often
- 歌がよく歌える or context-dependent uses could suggest sing well
In this sentence, because of the contrast with being shy in public, often is the natural meaning.
Why is it 歌っている instead of just 歌う at the end?
Both can refer to repeated actions, but 歌っている gives a sense of an ongoing habit or a state that is regularly observed.
So:
- 一人ではよく歌う = she often sings when alone
- 一人ではよく歌っている = when she is alone, she is often singing
The 〜ている form here suggests a habitual, commonly seen pattern rather than a simple plain statement.
It can feel a little more vivid, as if describing what she is like in real life.
Is 姉 always “older sister,” and can it refer to someone else’s older sister too?
姉 by itself means older sister, but whose older sister it refers to depends on context.
Commonly:
- 姉 = my older sister when talking about your own family to others
- お姉さん = someone else’s older sister, or a polite/friendly way to say older sister / young woman
So in this sentence, 姉 most naturally means my older sister.
What is the overall structure of the sentence?
It breaks down like this:
- 姉は — as for my older sister,
- 大勢の前で — in front of many people,
- 歌うのを — singing / the act of singing,
- 恥ずかしがる — she is shy about it,
- けれど — but,
- 一人では — when alone, by contrast,
- よく歌っている — she often sings
So the sentence has two main parts joined by けれど:
- She is shy about singing in front of many people
- But when she is alone, she often sings
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from ane ha oozei no mae de utauno wo hazukasigaru keredo, hitori de ha yoku utatte iru to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions