Breakdown of Adik saya tidak suka brokoli, tetapi dia tetap mencobanya.
Questions & Answers about Adik saya tidak suka brokoli, tetapi dia tetap mencobanya.
What does adik mean exactly? Does it mean younger brother or younger sister?
Adik means younger sibling. It does not specify gender.
So Adik saya can mean:
- my younger brother
- my younger sister
- more literally, my younger sibling
Indonesian often does not mark gender unless it is important to the context.
Why is it Adik saya and not saya adik?
In Indonesian, a possessive like my usually comes after the noun.
So:
- adik saya = my younger sibling
- rumah saya = my house
- buku saya = my book
This is different from English, where my comes before the noun.
Why is tidak used here?
Tidak is used to negate verbs and adjectives.
In this sentence:
- suka = to like
- tidak suka = do not like
So:
- Adik saya tidak suka brokoli = My younger sibling does not like broccoli
A useful contrast:
- tidak negates verbs/adjectives
- bukan usually negates nouns or noun phrases
For example:
- Saya tidak suka kopi. = I do not like coffee.
- Itu bukan kopi. = That is not coffee.
Is suka a verb here?
Yes. In this sentence, suka functions like to like.
So:
- dia suka brokoli = he/she likes broccoli
- dia tidak suka brokoli = he/she does not like broccoli
Indonesian often uses words that are less visibly marked than English verbs, so suka stays the same and does not change for person:
- saya suka
- dia suka
- mereka suka
What is the difference between tetapi and tapi?
Tetapi and tapi both mean but.
- tetapi is more formal or neutral in writing
- tapi is more common in everyday speech and informal writing
So this sentence uses the more formal/full form:
- ..., tetapi dia tetap mencobanya.
In casual conversation, many speakers would say:
- ..., tapi dia tetap mencobanya.
What does dia mean? Can it mean both he and she?
Yes. Dia can mean both he and she.
Indonesian third-person singular pronouns usually do not show gender:
- dia = he / she
- ia = a more formal written variant of dia
You understand the gender from context, if needed.
What does tetap mean in this sentence?
Here tetap means something like:
- still
- nevertheless
- anyway
- all the same
So dia tetap mencobanya means:
- he/she still tried it
- he/she tried it anyway
It shows that even though the sibling does not like broccoli, they tried it regardless.
Why is it mencobanya instead of just coba?
Mencobanya is built from:
- coba = try
- mencoba = to try
- -nya = it / him / her, depending on context
So:
- mencobanya = to try it
In this sentence, -nya refers to brokoli, so it means try it.
What is the function of the prefix meN- in mencoba?
The prefix meN- often forms an active verb.
Here:
- base word: coba
- active verb: mencoba = to try
This is a very common pattern in Indonesian. The prefix can change shape depending on the first sound of the root word. With coba, it becomes men-, giving mencoba.
You do not need to think of it as exactly the same as English verb endings; it is just part of how Indonesian commonly forms active verbs.
Why is -nya attached to the verb in mencobanya?
The suffix -nya here stands for it.
So:
- mencoba brokoli = to try broccoli
- mencobanya = to try it
This is very common in Indonesian. Once the object is known from context, -nya can replace it.
In this sentence:
- first mention: brokoli
- later reference: -nya = it = the broccoli
Could the sentence also say dia tetap mencoba brokoli?
Yes, absolutely.
These are both natural:
- dia tetap mencoba brokoli
- dia tetap mencobanya
The difference is:
- mencoba brokoli repeats the noun brokoli
- mencobanya uses it, referring back to brokoli
Using -nya often sounds smoother when the object has already been mentioned.
Is brokoli really the Indonesian word for broccoli?
Yes. Brokoli is the standard Indonesian spelling.
Many Indonesian words borrowed from other languages are adapted to Indonesian spelling:
- broccoli → brokoli
- television → televisi
- police → polisi
So brokoli is normal Indonesian.
Why is there no word for does in does not like?
Indonesian does not use a helper verb like English do/does in this kind of sentence.
English:
- My sibling does not like broccoli
Indonesian:
- Adik saya tidak suka brokoli
You simply put tidak before the verb:
- tidak suka = do/does not like
So Indonesian is structurally simpler here.
Is the word order in this sentence typical for Indonesian?
Yes. The word order is very typical.
The basic structure is:
- Adik saya = subject
- tidak suka = verb phrase
- brokoli = object
- tetapi = conjunction
- dia = subject
- tetap mencobanya = verb phrase + object marker
So the full sentence follows a normal Indonesian pattern similar to English:
- Subject + Verb + Object, then another clause joined by but
Could Adik saya also just mean my little sibling in a more general sense?
Yes, in many contexts adik can suggest a younger sibling or someone younger in relation to another person.
In family context, adik saya most naturally means my younger sibling.
But Indonesian also uses family terms socially, so adik can sometimes be used more loosely for a younger person. In this sentence, though, the most likely meaning is the actual younger sibling.
Why is the second clause dia tetap mencobanya instead of leaving out dia?
Including dia makes the second clause clear and complete:
- ..., tetapi dia tetap mencobanya.
In Indonesian, subjects can sometimes be omitted if the context is very clear, but keeping dia is natural and helps the sentence sound balanced.
So:
- ..., tetapi dia tetap mencobanya = clear and standard
- ..., tetapi tetap mencobanya = possible in context, but less explicit
The version with dia is especially good for learners because it clearly shows the subject of the second clause.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning IndonesianMaster Indonesian — from Adik saya tidak suka brokoli, tetapi dia tetap mencobanya to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions