Breakdown of Menurut dosen kami, angka pengangguran di kota besar itu masih tinggi.
Questions & Answers about Menurut dosen kami, angka pengangguran di kota besar itu masih tinggi.
Menurut means “according to” or “in the opinion of”.
- It introduces the source of an opinion or information: menurut dosen kami = “according to our lecturer”.
- It’s followed directly by a noun or pronoun: menurut saya (according to me), menurut berita (according to the news).
- You don’t need to add a word like pendapat (opinion); menurut dosen kami already means “in our lecturer’s opinion”.
In Indonesian, the normal order for possession is:
[thing] + [possessor pronoun]
So you say:
- dosen kami = our lecturer
- rumah saya = my house
- teman mereka = their friend
Kami dosen would sound like “we are lecturers” (and even that would usually be kami dosen followed by something else; on its own it’s odd). For “our lecturer”, you must use dosen kami.
Both mean “teacher”, but they’re used for different levels:
- dosen: a lecturer or instructor at a university or college.
- guru: a teacher at kindergarten, elementary, junior high, or high school.
So dosen kami = “our lecturer” / “our professor” (tertiary level), not a school teacher.
Indonesian has two words for “we” / “our”:
- kami = we / our, excluding the person being spoken to.
- kita = we / our, including the person being spoken to.
So:
- dosen kami = our lecturer (but not your lecturer).
- dosen kita = our lecturer, yours and mine (inclusive).
In this sentence, dosen kami suggests the speaker is talking about their lecturer to someone who is not in that same group (for example, telling a friend from another department).
Literally:
- angka = number, figure, rate
- pengangguran = unemployment / unemployed people
Together, angka pengangguran means “the unemployment rate” or “the number/figure of unemployed people”.
You could say just pengangguran di kota besar itu masih tinggi (“unemployment in that big city is still high”), but angka pengangguran makes it clearer you’re talking about a measurable statistic (a rate/figure), like in news or reports.
Pengangguran is a noun formed from the verb menganggur (to be unemployed / to be idle).
- Base verb: menganggur = to be unemployed
- Noun with pe- … -an: pengangguran = unemployment / the unemployed (as a group)
The pe- … -an pattern often turns verbs into abstract nouns:
- bekerja (to work) → pekerjaan (work, job)
- menganggur (to be unemployed) → pengangguran (unemployment)
Di is the basic preposition for “in / at / on” when talking about location.
- kota besar = big city
- itu = that / the (that specific one)
- di kota besar itu = in that big city / in the big city (that one)
You can’t omit di here.
Without di, kota besar itu would just be “that big city” as a noun phrase, not a location phrase.
In noun phrases, Indonesian word order is:
[noun] + [adjective] + [demonstrative (itu / ini)]
So you get:
- kota besar itu = that big city / the big city
- rumah merah itu = that red house
Kota itu besar is a sentence, not a noun phrase; it means “That city is big.”
So:
- kota besar itu → used inside a larger sentence as a noun phrase (“that big city”).
- kota itu besar → a full statement about the city (“that city is big”).
Itu basically means “that”, but in practice it often functions like “that/the (already known)”.
- kota besar itu can be translated as “that big city” (pointing to a specific city) or “the big city” (one that both speaker and listener already know about from context).
So itu marks the noun as specific / previously mentioned / identifiable, similar to English “that” or “the” depending on context.
Masih means “still” in the sense of “continuing, not yet changed.”
- masih tinggi = still high (has not gone down yet)
It implies there was an expectation or hope that the unemployment rate would decrease, but up to now it remains high.
Compare:
- angka pengangguran … tinggi = the unemployment rate is high (neutral statement)
- angka pengangguran … masih tinggi = the unemployment rate is still high (it hasn’t improved)
Indonesian normally does not use a verb like “to be” between a noun and an adjective.
So:
- Angka pengangguran … tinggi ≈ “The unemployment rate is high.”
- Angka pengangguran … masih tinggi ≈ “The unemployment rate is still high.”
The structure is simply:
[subject] + [adjective (possibly with adverb like masih)]
A copula like English “is/are” is usually unnecessary in this kind of sentence.
Yes, that word order is perfectly natural:
- Angka pengangguran di kota besar itu masih tinggi, menurut dosen kami.
This is like saying: “The unemployment rate in that big city is still high, according to our lecturer.”
Placing menurut dosen kami at the start or at the end mostly changes emphasis, not meaning:
- At the start: emphasizes the source first.
- At the end: presents the statement first, then attributes it to the lecturer.
You can say:
- di kota besar itu
- di kota besar tersebut
Both can mean “in that big city” / “in the big city (in question)”.
Differences:
- itu: more neutral, common in speech and writing.
- tersebut: a bit more formal, often used in written reports, news, official documents, and it strongly signals “the one that was mentioned before.”
In everyday conversation, itu is more common; in formal writing, tersebut is very frequent.