Breakdown of Die Scheibenwischer sind alt, aber sie reinigen die Windschutzscheibe noch gut genug.
Questions & Answers about Die Scheibenwischer sind alt, aber sie reinigen die Windschutzscheibe noch gut genug.
Why is it die Scheibenwischer? I thought die was for feminine nouns.
Here die is the plural definite article, not a feminine singular article.
- der Scheibenwischer = the windshield wiper
- die Scheibenwischer = the windshield wipers
In German, all plural nouns use die in the nominative.
What is the singular of Scheibenwischer?
The singular is der Scheibenwischer.
This noun has the same form in singular and plural:
- der Scheibenwischer = the windshield wiper
- die Scheibenwischer = the windshield wipers
That is very common in German, especially with some nouns ending in -er.
How are the compound nouns Scheibenwischer and Windschutzscheibe built?
German often combines smaller words into one long noun.
Scheibenwischer = Scheibe
- Wischer
Literally something like pane/window wiper
- Wischer
Windschutzscheibe = Wind
- Schutz
- Scheibe
Literally wind-protection pane, which is the normal German word for windshield
- Scheibe
- Schutz
The last part usually determines the grammatical gender:
- der Wischer → der Scheibenwischer
- die Scheibe → die Windschutzscheibe
Why is it sind alt and not sind alte?
Because alt comes after the verb sein and works as a predicate adjective.
After sein, adjectives usually do not take endings:
- Die Scheibenwischer sind alt.
- Das Auto ist schnell.
- Die Straße ist nass.
You only add an adjective ending when the adjective comes before a noun:
- alte Scheibenwischer = old windshield wipers
So:
- Die Scheibenwischer sind alt. ✅
- Die Scheibenwischer sind alte. ❌
Why is the second clause aber sie reinigen...? Does aber affect word order?
Aber is a coordinating conjunction. It connects two main clauses, but it does not force the verb to the end.
So the second clause keeps normal main-clause word order, where the finite verb is in second position:
- aber sie reinigen die Windschutzscheibe noch gut genug
Structure:
- aber = conjunction
- sie = subject
- reinigen = finite verb
- die Windschutzscheibe = object
Compare with a subordinating conjunction like weil, which would move the verb:
- ..., weil sie die Windschutzscheibe noch gut genug reinigen.
What does sie mean here?
Here sie means they, referring back to die Scheibenwischer.
German sie can mean several different things depending on context:
- she
- they
- you (formal, written Sie)
In this sentence, the verb form tells you it must be they:
- sie reinigen = they clean
- sie reinigt = she/it cleans
Because the verb is reinigen (plural), sie must be plural here.
Why is it die Windschutzscheibe and not der Windschutzscheibe?
Because Windschutzscheibe is the direct object of reinigen, and the noun itself is feminine:
- nominative: die Windschutzscheibe
- accusative: die Windschutzscheibe
For feminine singular nouns, the definite article is die in both nominative and accusative.
So even though the case changes, the article looks the same.
Compare with a masculine noun, where you would see the change more clearly:
- nominative: der Spiegel
- accusative: den Spiegel
Why doesn’t the article show the accusative clearly here?
Because German articles do not always change visibly in every gender.
For feminine singular:
- nominative: die
- accusative: die
So in this sentence, you know die Windschutzscheibe is the object mainly because of the verb reinigen and the sentence structure, not because the article changes form.
What does noch mean here?
Here noch means something like still.
It adds the idea that, even though the windshield wipers are old, they still do the job well enough.
So noch gives a sense of continuation:
- they are old
- but they still clean the windshield well enough
Without noch, the sentence would still be grammatical, but it would lose that extra nuance.
Why is it gut genug and not genug gut?
In German, genug usually comes after the adjective or adverb it modifies.
So:
- gut genug = good enough
- schnell genug = fast enough
- groß genug = big enough
That is the normal pattern.
So in this sentence:
- noch gut genug = still well enough / still good enough
Why is gut used here if reinigen is a verb? Shouldn’t it be something else?
Here gut is functioning adverbially. In German, the same form is often used for both the adjective and the adverb.
So:
- ein guter Scheibenwischer = a good windshield wiper
- Die Scheibenwischer reinigen gut. = The windshield wipers clean well.
Unlike English, German usually does not add a special -ly ending. The plain adjective form often does the job.
Why is there a comma before aber?
Because aber is connecting two main clauses:
- Die Scheibenwischer sind alt
- sie reinigen die Windschutzscheibe noch gut genug
In German, a comma is normally used before aber when it joins full clauses like this.
So the comma is not optional here in standard writing.
Could you also say wischen instead of reinigen?
Yes, depending on the exact nuance.
- reinigen focuses on cleaning
- wischen focuses more on the wiping motion
With windshield wipers, wischen is very natural because that is literally what they do.
But reinigen is also understandable and emphasizes the result: the windshield gets cleaned.
So this sentence is fine, but a learner might also come across sentences with wischen.
Why is Windschutzscheibe one long word instead of several words?
Because German normally writes compound nouns as one word.
So:
- Windschutzscheibe ✅
- Wind Schutz Scheibe ❌
This is one of the most important spelling habits in German. Long noun compounds may look difficult at first, but they are very normal and very common.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Die Scheibenwischer sind alt, aber sie reinigen die Windschutzscheibe noch gut genug to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions