Breakdown of Im Flur ist die Glühbirne kaputt, deshalb bleibt die Jalousie heute offen.
Questions & Answers about Im Flur ist die Glühbirne kaputt, deshalb bleibt die Jalousie heute offen.
What does im mean, and why is it im Flur?
im is the contraction of in dem.
Here it is used because:
So:
- im Flur = in the hallway / in the corridor
If there were movement into the hallway, German would use the accusative instead:
- in den Flur = into the hallway
Why does the sentence begin with Im Flur instead of the subject?
German main clauses follow the verb-second rule. That means the finite verb must be in the second position, but the first position can be many different things:
- the subject
- a time phrase
- a place phrase
- another adverbial element
Here, Im Flur is placed first to set the scene:
- Im Flur ist die Glühbirne kaputt.
Because Im Flur takes the first slot, the verb ist must come next, and the subject die Glühbirne comes after it.
Why is it ist die Glühbirne kaputt and not die Glühbirne ist kaputt?
Both patterns are possible in German, but they mean slightly different things in terms of emphasis.
- Die Glühbirne ist kaputt. → starts with the subject
- Im Flur ist die Glühbirne kaputt. → starts with the location
In German, once something other than the subject is put first, the verb still has to stay in second position. That is why you get:
- Im Flur
- ist
- die Glühbirne
- kaputt
- die Glühbirne
- ist
This is a very common feature of German word order.
Why does kaputt have no ending?
Because kaputt is a predicate adjective here. After verbs like:
- sein = to be
- bleiben = to stay/remain
- werden = to become
German adjectives do not take adjective endings.
So:
- die Glühbirne ist kaputt
- die Jalousie bleibt offen
But before a noun, the adjective does take an ending:
- die kaputte Glühbirne
- die offene Jalousie
That is a very important contrast.
What is Glühbirne, and why is it die Glühbirne?
Glühbirne means light bulb.
It is feminine, so its basic dictionary form is:
- die Glühbirne
A useful extra point: German compound nouns usually take their gender from the last part of the word. The last part here is Birne, and die Birne is feminine, so the whole compound is feminine too:
- die Glühbirne
What does deshalb do to the word order?
deshalb means therefore, that’s why, or for that reason.
It is not a subordinating conjunction like weil. Instead, it is an adverb that starts a new main clause. Because it takes the first position in that clause, the verb must come immediately after it:
- deshalb bleibt die Jalousie heute offen
Not:
- deshalb die Jalousie bleibt heute offen
So the pattern is:
- deshalb
- verb
- subject
- ...
- subject
- verb
This is one of the most common learner questions about words like deshalb, dann, trotzdem, and daher.
Why is bleibt used here instead of just ist?
bleiben means to stay or to remain.
So:
- Die Jalousie bleibt offen = The blind stays/remains open
This emphasizes that it continues to be open or is left open.
If you said:
- Die Jalousie ist offen
that would simply describe its state: The blind is open.
So bleibt adds the idea of continuation.
Why does offen have no ending?
For the same reason as kaputt: it is a predicate adjective after bleiben.
So you say:
- die Jalousie bleibt offen
But before a noun:
- die offene Jalousie
No ending after bleiben, but an ending before a noun.
What exactly does Jalousie mean in German?
In German, die Jalousie usually means a blind or shutter, especially for a window.
It is a feminine noun:
- die Jalousie
Depending on context, English might translate it as:
- blind
- window blind
- shutter
Why is heute placed before offen?
In the second clause, heute is a time adverb, and its position is very natural there:
- deshalb bleibt die Jalousie heute offen
German often places time expressions in the middle of the clause, before the final adjective or complement.
This sounds normal and idiomatic. You could also move heute to the front for emphasis:
- Heute bleibt die Jalousie offen.
But in the original sentence, the focus is on the consequence introduced by deshalb, so heute stays later in the clause.
Why is there a comma before deshalb?
The sentence contains two main clauses:
- Im Flur ist die Glühbirne kaputt
- deshalb bleibt die Jalousie heute offen
The comma separates these two closely connected clauses.
A key point is that deshalb does not create a subordinate clause. The second part is still a normal main clause, which is why the verb comes early:
- deshalb bleibt ...
You could also write this as two sentences in many contexts:
- Im Flur ist die Glühbirne kaputt. Deshalb bleibt die Jalousie heute offen.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Im Flur ist die Glühbirne kaputt, deshalb bleibt die Jalousie heute offen to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions