Breakdown of Es regnet, trotzdem machen wir einen kurzen Spaziergang im Park.
Questions & Answers about Es regnet, trotzdem machen wir einen kurzen Spaziergang im Park.
Why does German say Es regnet with es?
With weather verbs like regnen, German normally uses a formal or dummy subject: es.
It does not refer to a real thing. It is just there because German sentences usually need a subject.
So:
- Es regnet = It’s raining
- Es schneit = It’s snowing
English does the same thing with it.
Why is regnet in the present tense? Does it mean it rains or it’s raining?
German Präsens often covers both meanings.
So Es regnet can mean:
- it rains
- it’s raining
In this sentence, the context clearly makes it mean it’s raining right now.
The same is true for machen wir:
- literally present tense
- in English, often best translated as we’re taking / we are going for
What exactly does trotzdem mean here?
Trotzdem means nevertheless, nonetheless, even so, or despite that.
It connects the two ideas like this:
- Es regnet = one fact
- trotzdem machen wir... = in spite of that fact, we still do it
So it marks a strong contrast.
Why is the word order trotzdem machen wir and not trotzdem wir machen?
Because trotzdem is not a subordinating conjunction like weil or obwohl.
It is a connecting adverb, and the clause after it is still a main clause. In a German main clause, the finite verb must be in second position.
Here:
- position 1: trotzdem
- position 2: machen
- then: wir
So:
- trotzdem machen wir... ✓
- trotzdem wir machen... ✗
Is trotzdem the same kind of word as aber?
No, not quite.
- aber is a coordinating conjunction
- Es regnet, aber wir machen einen Spaziergang.
- trotzdem is a conjunctive adverb
- Es regnet, trotzdem machen wir einen Spaziergang.
The meaning is similar, but the grammar is different.
A useful shortcut:
- aber behaves more like but
- trotzdem behaves more like nevertheless / even so
Why is there a comma after Es regnet?
Because the sentence contains two separate main clauses:
- Es regnet
- trotzdem machen wir einen kurzen Spaziergang im Park
The comma separates those two clauses in writing.
Why does German say einen Spaziergang machen? Why use machen?
Einen Spaziergang machen is a common German expression meaning to take a walk or to go for a walk.
German often uses machen in fixed expressions like this.
You could also say:
- Wir gehen im Park spazieren.
That means roughly the same thing:
- einen Spaziergang machen = take a walk
- spazieren gehen = go walking / go for a walk
Both are natural.
Why is it einen kurzen Spaziergang?
Because Spaziergang is the direct object of machen, so it is in the accusative case.
- dictionary form: der Spaziergang (masculine)
- masculine accusative with ein becomes einen
So:
- nominative: ein kurzer Spaziergang
- accusative: einen kurzen Spaziergang
That is also why the adjective becomes kurzen.
Why is the adjective kurzen and not kurzer?
The adjective ending changes because it has to match:
- the case: accusative
- the gender: masculine
- the article pattern: einen
So in einen kurzen Spaziergang:
- einen shows masculine accusative
- the adjective takes the ending -en
Compare:
- ein kurzer Spaziergang = nominative
- einen kurzen Spaziergang = accusative
Why is it im Park and not in den Park?
Because im means in dem, which is dative.
With in, German makes a very common distinction:
- location → dative
- direction toward a destination → accusative
So:
- im Park = in the park / located in the park
- in den Park = into the park
Here the park is the place where the walk happens, so im Park is the natural form.
Could I also say Obwohl es regnet, machen wir einen kurzen Spaziergang im Park?
Yes, absolutely. That is very natural too.
The difference is grammatical:
- trotzdem introduces a new main clause
- Es regnet, trotzdem machen wir...
- obwohl introduces a subordinate clause
- Obwohl es regnet, machen wir...
With obwohl, the verb goes to the end of the subordinate clause:
- obwohl es regnet
The meanings are very close:
- trotzdem = nevertheless / despite that
- obwohl = although / even though
Can trotzdem go somewhere else in the sentence?
Yes.
For example:
- Es regnet, trotzdem machen wir einen kurzen Spaziergang im Park.
- Es regnet. Wir machen trotzdem einen kurzen Spaziergang im Park.
Both are possible.
The difference is mainly emphasis:
- putting trotzdem first makes the contrast especially clear
- putting it later sounds more like we still go for a short walk
So the meaning stays similar, but the focus shifts a little.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Es regnet, trotzdem machen wir einen kurzen Spaziergang im Park to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions