Das Brot ist so knusprig, dass sogar mein Bruder noch ein Stück nimmt.

Questions & Answers about Das Brot ist so knusprig, dass sogar mein Bruder noch ein Stück nimmt.

Why does German use so ... dass here?

So ... dass is a very common pattern meaning so ... that.

  • so knusprig = so crispy
  • dass ... = that ...

So the structure is:

  • Das Brot ist so knusprig, dass ...
  • The bread is so crispy that ...

German uses this pattern just like English does.


Why is nimmt at the end of the sentence?

Because dass introduces a subordinate clause, and in German subordinate clauses the conjugated verb usually goes to the end.

Main clause:

  • Das Brot ist so knusprig

Subordinate clause:

  • dass sogar mein Bruder noch ein Stück nimmt

So nimmt goes to the end because of dass.

This is one of the most important German word-order rules to learn.


What is the difference between das and dass?

They are different words:

  • das = the or that as a pronoun/article
  • dass = that as a conjunction introducing a clause

In this sentence:

  • Das Brot = the bread
  • dass sogar mein Bruder ... nimmt = that even my brother takes ...

A useful shortcut:

  • If it introduces a whole clause with a verb at the end, it is usually dass.

What exactly does sogar mean here?

Sogar means even.

It adds the idea that this is somewhat surprising:

  • dass sogar mein Bruder noch ein Stück nimmt
  • that even my brother takes another piece

So the speaker is suggesting that the brother is maybe not usually interested, not easily impressed, or not expected to take more.

A close alternative is selbst in some contexts:

  • dass selbst mein Bruder noch ein Stück nimmt

Both can mean even, though sogar often sounds a little more explicitly emphatic.


What does noch mean in this sentence?

Here noch means something like another / one more / still depending on context.

In:

  • noch ein Stück nimmt

the most natural sense is takes another piece.

So noch is not just still here. It suggests an extra amount:

  • ein Stück = a piece
  • noch ein Stück = another piece / one more piece

This is a very common use of noch.


Why does it say ein Stück instead of just eins?

Because German often uses Stück to mean piece when talking about food or portions.

  • ein Stück Brot = a piece of bread
  • noch ein Stück = another piece

In this sentence, Brot is understood already, so ein Stück is enough.

You could think of it as:

  • another piece [of it]

Using eins would not sound as natural here, because the speaker is talking about a portion of bread, not just the number one by itself.


What case is mein Bruder, and why?

Mein Bruder is in the nominative case because it is the subject of nimmt.

Ask: who is taking another piece?

Answer: mein Bruder

So:

  • mein Bruder = subject = nominative

The sentence inside the dass clause is basically:

  • mein Bruder nimmt noch ein Stück

What case is ein Stück?

Ein Stück is in the accusative case because it is the direct object of nimmt.

Ask: what does my brother take?

Answer: ein Stück

So:

  • subject = mein Bruder (nominative)
  • object = ein Stück (accusative)

Here, ein Stück looks the same in nominative and accusative because Stück is neuter:

  • nominative: ein Stück
  • accusative: ein Stück

So the form does not change, but the function is accusative.


Why is knusprig not changed? Why is there no ending?

Because knusprig is being used as a predicate adjective, after the verb ist.

In German, adjectives used after verbs like sein, werden, and bleiben do not take adjective endings.

So:

  • Das Brot ist knusprig.

But before a noun, the adjective would need an ending:

  • das knusprige Brot

Compare:

  • Das Brot ist knusprig.
  • Ich esse das knusprige Brot.

Why is there a comma before dass?

Because in German, subordinate clauses are normally separated from the main clause by a comma.

Since dass sogar mein Bruder noch ein Stück nimmt is a subordinate clause, the comma is required:

  • Das Brot ist so knusprig, dass ...

This is a standard punctuation rule in German.


Why is the sentence in the present tense: nimmt?

German often uses the present tense in places where English might also use the present tense.

Here it can describe:

  • a current situation
  • a vivid observation
  • a general kind of statement

So nimmt simply means takes in this structure.

Depending on context, English might translate it a little differently:

  • that even my brother takes another piece
  • that even my brother is taking another piece
  • that even my brother will take another piece

But the German present tense itself is completely normal here.


Could I also say selbst mein Bruder instead of sogar mein Bruder?

Yes, often you can.

  • sogar mein Bruder
  • selbst mein Bruder

Both can mean even my brother.

However, sogar is especially common when emphasizing that something is surprising. In this sentence, sogar sounds very natural.

So:

  • dass sogar mein Bruder noch ein Stück nimmt = very natural
  • dass selbst mein Bruder noch ein Stück nimmt = also possible

Why does the sentence start with Das Brot and not just Brot?

German usually uses an article with nouns in many situations where English might also use one.

Here Das Brot means the bread. It refers to a specific bread, loaf, or bread being talked about.

Just Brot without an article is possible in some contexts, but it would usually sound more general or less natural here.

So:

  • Das Brot ist so knusprig ... = this/the bread is so crispy ...

That fits the sentence best.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
How do German cases work?
German has four grammatical cases: nominative (subject), accusative (direct object), dative (indirect object), and genitive (possession). The case determines the form of articles and adjectives. For example, "the dog" is "der Hund" as a subject but "den Hund" as a direct object.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning German

Master German — from Das Brot ist so knusprig, dass sogar mein Bruder noch ein Stück nimmt to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.

  • Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • AI tutor to answer your grammar questions