Breakdown of Nous étions en train de désherber quand nous avons vu une racine sous le vieux rosier.
Questions & Answers about Nous étions en train de désherber quand nous avons vu une racine sous le vieux rosier.
What does en train de mean here?
Être en train de + infinitive means to be in the middle of doing something or to be busy doing something.
So:
nous étions en train de désherber
= we were weeding / we were in the middle of weeding
It adds emphasis that the action was ongoing at that moment.
Why is it nous étions and not just nous avons été?
Why is désherber in the infinitive?
Could I say Nous désherbions instead?
Why are two different past tenses used: étions and avons vu?
Why is it avons vu and not voyions?
Because we saw a root is treated as a single completed event.
Nous avons vu means we saw in the sense of a finished moment of perception.
If you said nous voyions, it would suggest something more ongoing or habitual, such as we could see or we used to see, depending on context. That is not the idea here.
What does quand mean here, and does it affect the tense choice?
Here quand means when.
It introduces the moment when the second action happened:
We were weeding when we saw a root...
It does not automatically force one tense, but in this kind of sentence it often connects:
- an ongoing action in the imparfait
- with a completed event in the passé composé
So quand works very naturally with this tense contrast.
Why is nous repeated twice?
Because French normally requires an explicit subject pronoun with each conjugated verb.
So you say:
Nous étions ... quand nous avons vu ...
Even though English can sometimes avoid repetition more easily, French usually keeps the subject pronoun before each verb.
What does désherber mean exactly?
What does une racine mean, and why is it une?
What exactly is un rosier?
Un rosier is a rosebush or rose plant, not a single rose flower.
So:
- une rose = a rose
- un rosier = a rosebush
That is why sous le vieux rosier means under the old rosebush.
Why is it le vieux rosier and not le rosier vieux?
Why is it sous le vieux rosier and not sous un vieux rosier?
Could quand be replaced by lorsque?
Is there anything tricky about the pronunciation?
A few points may stand out:
- étions sounds roughly like ay-tyon
- désherber has a z sound at the start: day-zher-bay
- rosier sounds roughly like ro-zee-ay
- vu has the French u sound, which is different from English oo
A rough pronunciation of the whole sentence is:
Noo zay-tyon ahn tran duh day-zher-bay, kahn noo zah-von vyoo oon ra-seen soo luh vyuh ro-zee-ay.
That is only an approximation, but it can help you get started.
Is this a natural French sentence?
Yes, it sounds natural.
It is a good example of a very common French storytelling pattern:
- background action in the imparfait
- sudden or completed event in the passé composé
A native speaker might also simply say Nous désherbions quand nous avons vu..., but the sentence as given is perfectly normal and clear.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Nous étions en train de désherber quand nous avons vu une racine sous le vieux rosier to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions