Breakdown of Mia avino diras, ke salato kun oleo estas pli bona ol salato sen oleo.
Questions & Answers about Mia avino diras, ke salato kun oleo estas pli bona ol salato sen oleo.
Why is ke used after diras?
Ke introduces a subordinate clause and usually corresponds to English that.
So:
Mia avino diras, ke...
= My grandmother says that...
In English, that is often omitted, but in Esperanto ke is normally kept.
Why is there a comma before ke?
In normal Esperanto writing, a comma is commonly placed before a subordinate clause introduced by ke.
So diras, ke... is standard punctuation.
You will often see the same thing with other clause-introducing words too.
What does the -as ending mean in diras and estas?
The ending -as marks the present tense.
- diras = says / is saying
- estas = is / are / am
Esperanto verbs do not change according to the subject, so the same -as form works with mi, vi, ŝi, ili, and so on.
How does pli bona ol mean better than?
Esperanto makes comparisons with pli + adjective.
- bona = good
- pli bona = more good = better
- ol = than
So:
pli bona ol = better than
This is the normal Esperanto comparative pattern.
Why is it bona, not bonan?
Because bona is not a direct object here. It is a predicate adjective after estas.
In the clause:
salato ... estas pli bona
the subject is salato, and bona describes that subject. Predicate adjectives stay in the basic adjective form unless they need plural or accusative agreement for other grammatical reasons.
So bona is correct, not bonan.
What do kun and sen mean?
They are prepositions:
- kun = with
- sen = without
So:
- salato kun oleo = salad with oil
- salato sen oleo = salad without oil
After prepositions like these, the noun is normally just in its basic form, so oleo, not oleon.
Why is there no la before salato or oleo?
Because the sentence is talking about salad and oil in a general way, not about one specific salad or one specific oil already known to the listener.
Esperanto uses la when the noun is definite or specifically identified.
So here:
- salato kun oleo = salad with oil, in general
- salato sen oleo = salad without oil, in general
If you meant a particular salad, then la might be needed.
Why is mia in the -a form?
Because Esperanto possessives behave like adjectives.
mia comes from mi and means my, but grammatically it works like an adjective, so it has the ending -a.
That also means it can agree with the noun:
- mia avino = my grandmother
- miaj avinoj = my grandmothers
- mian avinon = my grandmother, as a direct object
Here it is singular and not accusative, so mia is the correct form.
What is going on inside the word avino?
Avino is built from:
- av- = grandparent/grandfather root
- -in- = female suffix
- -o = noun ending
So avino means grandmother.
This is a very common Esperanto word-building pattern. For example:
- frato = brother
fratino = sister
- patro = father
- patrino = mother
Why is salato repeated after ol?
The repetition makes the comparison very clear.
The sentence compares:
- salato kun oleo with
- salato sen oleo
Repeating salato shows that these are two kinds of salad being compared.
Esperanto often repeats a noun when that makes the meaning cleaner and less ambiguous. Even if English might sometimes avoid the repetition, Esperanto is perfectly comfortable with it.
Is the word order here especially important?
This sentence uses very normal, straightforward Esperanto word order.
Main clause:
Mia avino diras...
Subordinate clause:
ke salato kun oleo estas pli bona ol salato sen oleo
Inside that clause, the structure is:
- subject: salato kun oleo
- verb: estas
- complement: pli bona
- comparison: ol salato sen oleo
Esperanto word order is somewhat flexible, but this version is the most neutral and easiest for learners to follow.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning EsperantoMaster Esperanto — from Mia avino diras, ke salato kun oleo estas pli bona ol salato sen oleo to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions