Breakdown of Anna heeft pijn in haar enkel, maar haar been voelt verder goed aan.
Questions & Answers about Anna heeft pijn in haar enkel, maar haar been voelt verder goed aan.
Why does Dutch say heeft pijn here? Why not something like is pijnlijk?
In Dutch, the normal way to say someone is in pain is pijn hebben = to have pain.
So:
- Anna heeft pijn = Anna is in pain
- more literally: Anna has pain
You can use pijnlijk in some contexts, but it means painful, not simply in pain:
- Haar enkel is pijnlijk = Her ankle is painful
That is grammatically fine, but pijn hebben is the most common everyday wording for a person experiencing pain.
Why is it in haar enkel?
Dutch often uses pijn in to indicate where the pain is located:
- pijn in mijn rug = pain in my back
- pijn in haar knie = pain in her knee
- pijn in zijn enkel = pain in his ankle
So pijn in haar enkel is the normal way to say pain in her ankle.
Does enkel really mean ankle? I thought enkel meant only.
Yes, enkel can mean two different things.
As a noun:
- de enkel = the ankle
As an adjective/adverb:
- enkel = only, single
In this sentence, haar enkel clearly means her ankle, because it is being used as a body part noun.
So:
- haar enkel = her ankle
- enkel een vraag = only one question
Why is haar used twice?
Because Dutch repeats the possessive pronoun with each noun, just like English usually does here:
- haar enkel = her ankle
- haar been = her leg
So the sentence says:
- Anna heeft pijn in haar enkel, maar haar been voelt verder goed aan.
This is completely normal. Dutch does not usually avoid the second haar just because it refers to the same person.
What does been mean here?
Been means leg.
So:
- haar been = her leg
This is a useful false friend to notice, because English been has nothing to do with the Dutch noun been.
Also, pronunciation is different from English been:
- Dutch been is pronounced more like bayn
What does verder mean in this sentence?
Here verder means something like:
- otherwise
- apart from that
- besides that
So:
- maar haar been voelt verder goed aan means
- but otherwise her leg feels fine
- but apart from that her leg feels fine
It adds the idea that there is a problem with the ankle, but the rest of the leg seems okay.
Why is aan at the end of the sentence?
Because the verb is aanvoelen, which is a separable verb in Dutch.
The full verb is:
- aanvoelen = to feel, to seem to feel, to feel to the touch
In a main clause, Dutch often splits separable verbs:
- voelt ... aan
So:
- haar been voelt goed aan literally:
- her leg feels good on
But in natural English:
- her leg feels fine
- her leg feels okay
This splitting is very common in Dutch:
- opstaan → ik sta op
- meenemen → ik neem mee
- aanvoelen → het voelt goed aan
What does goed aanvoelen mean exactly?
Goed aanvoelen means to feel fine / feel okay / feel normal.
In this sentence, it suggests that the leg does not seem to have a problem apart from the ankle.
A few examples:
- De plek voelt warm aan. = The spot feels warm.
- Mijn knie voelt stijf aan. = My knee feels stiff.
- Haar been voelt goed aan. = Her leg feels fine / feels normal.
So voelt goed aan is about how something feels, often physically.
Why is the word order maar haar been voelt verder goed aan?
Because maar is a coordinating conjunction, much like but in English. After maar, you normally get regular main-clause word order.
So:
- Anna heeft pijn in haar enkel
- maar haar been voelt verder goed aan
In the second clause:
- haar been = subject
- voelt = finite verb
- verder goed = adverb + adjective
- aan = separated verb particle
This is standard Dutch main-clause order.
Why is there no article before pijn?
Because pijn is usually treated as an uncountable noun here, like pain in English.
So Dutch says:
- pijn hebben = to have pain
- pijn in mijn arm = pain in my arm
You normally do not say een pijn in this kind of sentence.
Could you also say Anna’s enkel doet pijn?
Yes. That is another very common way to express this idea.
For example:
- Anna’s enkel doet pijn.
- Haar enkel doet pijn.
This literally means Her ankle hurts.
So Dutch has at least two very natural patterns here:
- Anna heeft pijn in haar enkel. = Anna has pain in her ankle.
- Haar enkel doet pijn. = Her ankle hurts.
Both are correct and common.
Is been here the whole leg, or can it sometimes mean something else?
In everyday Dutch, been usually means the whole leg.
If you specifically want to say lower leg, Dutch often uses:
- onderbeen = lower leg
And for thigh:
- bovenbeen = upper leg / thigh
So in this sentence, haar been means her leg in general, not a more specific section unless the context says so.
Is this a natural everyday Dutch sentence?
Yes, it sounds natural.
It has a very normal structure:
- problem stated first: Anna heeft pijn in haar enkel
- contrast added after maar: haar been voelt verder goed aan
A native speaker would understand it immediately as:
- the ankle hurts,
- but the rest of the leg seems fine.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning DutchMaster Dutch — from Anna heeft pijn in haar enkel, maar haar been voelt verder goed aan to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions