Breakdown of Zonder muis kan Anna moeilijk tekenen, dus leent zij de muis van haar collega.
Questions & Answers about Zonder muis kan Anna moeilijk tekenen, dus leent zij de muis van haar collega.
Why is there no article before muis in Zonder muis?
After zonder, Dutch often leaves out the article when speaking generally about lacking something: zonder jas, zonder bril, zonder muis. It means Anna does not have a mouse available.
You could also say zonder een muis, but that sounds more emphatic or more like without any mouse / without a particular mouse.
And zonder de muis would mean without the mouse, referring to a specific one.
Why is kan before Anna in Zonder muis kan Anna moeilijk tekenen?
This is because Dutch main clauses normally follow the verb-second rule. The finite verb must be in the second position.
Here, Zonder muis takes the first position, so the finite verb kan comes next, and the subject Anna comes after that:
- Zonder muis = first position
- kan = finite verb, second position
- Anna = subject
If the subject came first, the sentence could be:
Anna kan zonder muis moeilijk tekenen.
Both are correct, but the original sentence puts extra focus on zonder muis.
Why is tekenen at the end of the clause?
Because kan is a modal verb. In Dutch, when you use a modal verb such as kunnen, moeten, willen, or mogen, the other verb usually goes to the end of the clause.
So:
- kan = finite modal verb
- tekenen = main verb, placed at the end
That is why you get:
kan Anna moeilijk tekenen
and not kan Anna tekenen moeilijk.
What is moeilijk doing here? Is it an adjective or an adverb?
Here moeilijk works as an adverb: it describes tekenen.
Dutch often uses the same form for both adjective and adverb. English usually distinguishes between difficult and difficultly, but Dutch normally just uses moeilijk.
So moeilijk tekenen means:
- to draw with difficulty
- to find drawing difficult
Why does the second clause say dus leent zij instead of dus zij leent?
Again, this is the verb-second rule.
In the second clause, dus takes the first position. Since Dutch main clauses still want the finite verb in second position, leent must come next, and the subject zij follows it:
- dus = first position
- leent = finite verb, second position
- zij = subject
So dus leent zij is the normal Dutch order here.
Dus zij leent is not standard main-clause word order in this sentence.
Does zij mean she or they here?
Zij can mean either she or they, depending on the context.
Here it means she, because it refers back to Anna, which is singular. The verb also confirms that:
- zij leent = she borrows
- zij lenen = they borrow
So the form leent shows that this is singular.
Why use zij instead of ze?
Both are possible.
- zij is the full, stressed form
- ze is the unstressed, more everyday form
In writing, especially slightly more careful or formal writing, zij is common. In casual speech, many people would say:
dus leent ze de muis van haar collega
That would sound very natural too.
Why is it de muis in the second clause, when the first clause just has muis?
In the first clause, muis is mentioned in a general sense: Anna cannot really draw if she has no mouse available.
In the second clause, the sentence refers to a specific mouse, namely the one she borrows. That is why Dutch uses the definite article:
de muis
So the contrast is roughly:
- zonder muis = without a mouse, in general
- de muis = the mouse, a specific one in the situation
Why is it van haar collega? Is van required with lenen?
Yes. In Dutch, lenen is commonly used like this:
- iets lenen van iemand = to borrow something from someone
So in this sentence:
- leent ... de muis = borrows the mouse
- van haar collega = from her colleague
So van is the normal preposition here.
Does haar collega mean the colleague is female?
No. Haar here refers to Anna, not to the colleague's gender.
So haar collega means her colleague, and that colleague could be male or female. The noun collega itself does not tell you the gender.
If you wanted to specify, you could say:
- haar mannelijke collega = her male colleague
- haar vrouwelijke collega = her female colleague
Does muis also mean a computer mouse in Dutch?
Yes. Dutch uses muis for both the animal and the computer device.
Usually the context makes it clear which one is meant. In this sentence, because of tekenen and lenen, it is naturally understood as a computer mouse.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning DutchMaster Dutch — from Zonder muis kan Anna moeilijk tekenen, dus leent zij de muis van haar collega to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions