Breakdown of Min datter spørger, om hun også må holde fiskestangen, men kun hvis en voksen hjælper hende.
Questions & Answers about Min datter spørger, om hun også må holde fiskestangen, men kun hvis en voksen hjælper hende.
Why is it min datter and not min datteren?
Because min already makes the noun phrase definite in Danish.
- min datter = my daughter
- You normally do not add the definite ending when you use a possessive like min, din, hans, vores, etc.
So:
- datter = daughter
- datteren = the daughter
- min datter = my daughter
Using min datteren would be incorrect in standard Danish.
What tense is spørger, and why isn’t it translated literally as only asks?
Spørger is present tense of spørge = to ask.
In Danish, the present tense often covers situations where English might use either:
- asks
- is asking
So Min datter spørger can mean:
- My daughter asks
- My daughter is asking
The exact English choice depends on context.
Why is om used after spørger?
Here om introduces an indirect yes/no question.
In English, we often say:
- She asks if...
- She asks whether...
In Danish, that if/whether is usually om in this kind of sentence.
So:
- Min datter spørger, om hun også må... = My daughter asks if/whether she may also...
Important: this om does not mean about here. It is a conjunction introducing an indirect question.
Why is the word order om hun også må and not om også hun må?
Because in a subordinate clause introduced by om, Danish does not use normal main-clause V2 word order.
The usual pattern here is:
- conjunction + subject + sentence adverb + finite verb
So:
- om = conjunction
- hun = subject
- også = adverb
- må = finite verb
That gives:
- om hun også må...
This is very typical Danish subordinate-clause word order.
What does må mean here?
Here må means may / is allowed to.
So hun også må holde fiskestangen means:
- she may also hold the fishing rod
- she is also allowed to hold the fishing rod
It expresses permission, not ability.
That is different from:
- kan = can, is able to
- må = may, is allowed to, must (depending on context)
In this sentence, må clearly means is allowed to.
Could må be replaced with kan here?
Not if you want the same meaning.
- må holde fiskestangen = is allowed to hold the fishing rod
- kan holde fiskestangen = is able to hold the fishing rod / can hold it
Since the daughter is asking for permission, må is the natural choice.
If you used kan, it would sound like she is asking about ability, not permission.
Why is også placed before må?
Because også is functioning as an adverb meaning also / too, and in this subordinate clause it comes before the finite verb.
So:
- hun også må holde fiskestangen = she may also hold the fishing rod
This placement is normal in Danish subordinate clauses.
Compare the rough structure:
- hun = subject
- også = also
- må = may
- holde = hold
Why is it holde fiskestangen and not something with at?
Because after a modal verb like må, Danish uses the infinitive without at.
So:
- må holde = may hold
- not må at holde
This is like English:
- may hold
- not may to hold
Common Danish modal verbs that behave this way include:
- kan = can
- vil = will/want to
- skal = shall/must
- må = may/must
- bør = ought to
Why is fiskestangen one word, and what does the -en ending do?
Danish often forms compound nouns as a single word.
- fiske relates to fishing
- stang = rod
- fiskestang = fishing rod
Then the ending -en makes it definite:
- fiskestang = a fishing rod
- fiskestangen = the fishing rod
So holde fiskestangen means hold the fishing rod.
This is very common in Danish: compounds are usually written as one word.
Why does the sentence use men kun hvis?
Men means but, and kun hvis means only if.
So:
- men = but
- kun hvis = only if
Together:
- men kun hvis en voksen hjælper hende = but only if an adult helps her
This adds a condition to the permission.
What is the difference between om and hvis in this sentence?
They both can sometimes relate to English if, but they do different jobs here.
om introduces an indirect question:
- spørger, om hun også må...
- asks if/whether she may also...
hvis introduces a condition:
- kun hvis en voksen hjælper hende
- only if an adult helps her
So in this sentence:
- om = whether/if
- hvis = if in the conditional sense
This is an important distinction in Danish.
Why is it en voksen? Is voksen really a noun here?
Yes. Voksen can be both an adjective and a noun depending on how it is used.
Here it means:
- an adult
So en voksen is a noun phrase.
Compare:
- en voksen person = an adult person
- en voksen = an adult
This is very natural Danish.
Why is it hjælper hende and not hjælper hun or hjælper hendes?
Because hende is the object form of hun.
- hun = she
- hende = her
Since hjælper takes an object here, Danish uses hende:
- en voksen hjælper hende = an adult helps her
And hendes means her in the possessive sense, like her book, so it would not fit here.
Can hjælper hende also imply helping her do the action, not just helping her in general?
Yes. In this sentence, that is exactly how it is understood.
- en voksen hjælper hende means an adult helps her, specifically in the situation of holding the fishing rod.
Danish does not need an extra phrase like with it if the context is already clear. The meaning is understood from the sentence as a whole.
Why are there commas before om and before men?
Because Danish punctuation commonly separates clauses with commas.
Here the sentence has several parts:
- Min datter spørger
- om hun også må holde fiskestangen
- men kun hvis en voksen hjælper hende
The comma before om marks the start of the subordinate clause, and the comma before men separates the next clause.
Comma rules in Danish are not identical to English comma rules, so learners often notice more commas in Danish sentences than they expect.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning DanishMaster Danish — from Min datter spørger, om hun også må holde fiskestangen, men kun hvis en voksen hjælper hende to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions