Breakdown of Si al gener o al desembre hi ha neu, la meva filla vol tocar el gel amb guants.
Questions & Answers about Si al gener o al desembre hi ha neu, la meva filla vol tocar el gel amb guants.
Why does the sentence start with Si?
Si means if and introduces a condition.
In this sentence, Si al gener o al desembre hi ha neu... sets up the situation, and the rest of the sentence tells you what happens in that case.
Also, after si, Catalan normally uses the indicative, not the subjunctive, for real or possible conditions like this one:
- Si hi ha neu... = If there is snow...
Why is it al gener and al desembre?
Al is the contraction of a + el.
So:
- al gener = in January
- al desembre = in December
Catalan often uses the article with months in expressions of time. English just says in January, but Catalan commonly says al gener.
The al is repeated before both months because each month belongs to its own time expression:
- al gener o al desembre
What does hi ha mean, and why is hi there?
Hi ha means there is or there are.
Examples:
- Hi ha neu = There is snow
- Hi ha dos llibres = There are two books
The hi is a fixed part of this existential expression. A learner often wants to treat ha alone as there is, but in Catalan the normal expression is hi ha.
So you should learn hi ha as one unit.
Why is it hi ha neu and not la neu?
After hi ha, Catalan often uses a noun without a definite article when introducing something that exists or is present.
So:
- hi ha neu = there is snow
This is similar to English, where you also usually say there is snow, not there is the snow, unless you mean some specific snow already identified.
If you were talking about specific snow, you might use la neu, but not in this basic existential structure.
Why is it la meva filla instead of just meva filla?
In Catalan, possessives are very often used together with the definite article:
- la meva filla = my daughter
- el meu germà = my brother
- les nostres amigues = our friends
This is one of the big differences from English. English usually says just my daughter, but Catalan normally says the my daughter structurally, even though it translates simply as my daughter.
Why is it vol tocar? Why is there no extra word for to?
Vol is the 3rd person singular of voler = to want.
In Catalan, after voler, you usually put the infinitive directly:
- vol tocar = wants to touch
- vol menjar = wants to eat
- vol dormir = wants to sleep
English uses to before the infinitive, but Catalan does not need an extra word here.
Why is it el gel? Does gel need the article?
Here gel means ice, and el gel is the natural form in this sentence.
Catalan often uses the definite article where English may or may not use one. In context, el gel refers to the ice present in that situation, so the ice is a natural translation.
Also, gel is a masculine noun:
- el gel
Does gel mean ice or cold?
In this sentence, gel means ice.
That matters because English learners sometimes confuse:
- gel = ice
- fred = cold
So:
- tocar el gel = to touch the ice
- tenir fred = to be cold
Why is it amb guants and not amb els guants?
Amb guants means with gloves or wearing gloves in a general sense.
When Catalan is not referring to a specific pair already identified, it often leaves out the article:
- amb guants = with gloves / wearing gloves
If you said amb els guants, that would sound more like with the gloves, meaning specific gloves known from context.
So in this sentence, amb guants is the most natural choice.
Is the sentence talking about one specific moment, or a general habit?
With the present tense, it can sound like a general or repeated situation:
- Si ... hi ha neu, la meva filla vol tocar el gel... = Whenever/if there is snow, my daughter wants to touch the ice...
So it can describe a typical reaction or a general truth about your daughter.
If you wanted to make the future idea more explicit, Catalan could use future forms in other contexts, but the present is very common for general conditions.
Why is there a comma after neu?
The comma separates the initial conditional clause from the main clause:
- Si al gener o al desembre hi ha neu,
la meva filla vol tocar el gel amb guants.
This is very natural and standard when a conditional clause comes first. It helps the reader see where the condition ends and the main statement begins.
Could the word order be changed?
Yes. Catalan is somewhat flexible.
For example, you could also say:
- La meva filla vol tocar el gel amb guants si al gener o al desembre hi ha neu.
That still makes sense, but the original version is very natural because it presents the condition first and then the result.
So the original order is a good, clear default:
- condition
- main clause
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Si al gener o al desembre hi ha neu, la meva filla vol tocar el gel amb guants to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions