La meva mare diu que la carnisseria que és prop de l'estació té carn i ous.

Questions & Answers about La meva mare diu que la carnisseria que és prop de l'estació té carn i ous.

Why does Catalan say la meva mare instead of just meva mare?

In Catalan, it is very common to use the definite article with family members and possessives:

  • la meva mare = my mother
  • el meu pare = my father

This is different from English, which normally does not use the in phrases like my mother.

So:

  • la meva mare diu... literally looks like the my mother says...
  • but the natural English meaning is simply my mother says...

This article is especially common in standard Catalan with singular family nouns.

What does diu que mean, and why is que there?

diu means says, from the verb dir = to say.

que here means that and introduces the content of what is being said:

  • La meva mare diu que...
  • My mother says that...

In English, that is often optional:

  • My mother says the butcher’s shop...
  • My mother says that the butcher’s shop...

In Catalan, que is normally kept.

Why are there two que words in the sentence?

They do two different jobs.

  1. diu que
    Here que means that and introduces a clause:

    • My mother says that...
  2. la carnisseria que és prop de l'estació
    Here que is a relative pronoun, meaning that/which:

    • the butcher’s shop that is near the station

So the sentence has:

  • one que = that after diu
  • one que = that/which after carnisseria
What exactly does carnisseria mean?

carnisseria means butcher’s shop or butcher shop.

It comes from:

  • carn = meat
  • carnisser / carnissera = butcher
  • carnisseria = butcher’s shop

So la carnisseria is the place where meat is sold.

Why does que és prop de l'estació come after la carnisseria?

Because it describes which butcher’s shop we are talking about.

  • la carnisseria = the butcher’s shop
  • que és prop de l'estació = that is near the station

Together:

  • la carnisseria que és prop de l'estació
  • the butcher’s shop that is near the station

This relative clause directly modifies la carnisseria, not la meva mare.

What does prop de mean?

prop de means near or close to.

Examples:

  • prop de l'estació = near the station
  • prop de casa = near home

A useful thing to remember is that prop normally goes with de before the noun:

  • prop de l'escola
  • prop del mercat

You may also see a prop de, which is also very common:

  • és a prop de l'estació = it is near the station
Why is it de l'estació and not de la estació?

Because Catalan usually contracts or elides the article before a vowel.

  • la estació becomes l'estació
  • so de + l'estació = de l'estació

This is similar to how Catalan writes:

  • l'escola
  • l'home
  • l'amiga

So:

  • prop de l'estació = near the station
Why is estació feminine?

Because estació is a feminine noun in Catalan, so it takes feminine articles:

  • l'estació
  • una estació
  • aquesta estació

You simply have to learn the gender of nouns as part of the word. In this case:

  • estació = feminine
Why is it with an accent?

is the he/she/it form of tenir (to have):

  • jo tinc = I have
  • tu tens = you have
  • ell/ella té = he/she/it has

The accent is important because it distinguishes from te.

Here:

  • la carnisseria ... té carn i ous
  • the butcher’s shop ... has meat and eggs
Why is there no article before carn and ous?

In Catalan, when talking about things in a general or indefinite way, nouns often appear without an article.

So:

  • té carn i ous = it has meat and eggs

This sounds natural in Catalan. English does something similar here too:

  • we say it has meat and eggs, not usually it has the meat and the eggs

If the sentence were referring to specific meat or specific eggs, the wording might be different.

Is ous singular or plural?

ous is plural.

  • ou = egg
  • ous = eggs

So:

  • carn i ous = meat and eggs

A learner may notice that ou becomes ous, not something like ousos or another pattern. It is just the normal plural form of this noun.

How do I know that refers to la carnisseria and not l'estació?

Because of the structure of the sentence.

The main subject of the embedded clause is:

  • la carnisseria ... té carn i ous

The part que és prop de l'estació is just extra information describing la carnisseria.

So the structure is:

  • La meva mare diu
  • [que [la carnisseria [que és prop de l'estació]] té carn i ous]

That means:

  • the butcher’s shop is near the station
  • and the butcher’s shop has meat and eggs

Not:

  • the station has meat and eggs
Could Catalan also say que està prop de l'estació instead of que és prop de l'estació?

Yes, you may hear both, depending on style and context.

  • és prop de = is near
  • està prop de = also is near

In many real-life contexts, estar is very common for location:

  • La carnisseria està prop de l'estació

But és prop de is also understandable and acceptable in many contexts. For a learner, the key point is that prop de means near, whether the verb used is és or està.

Is the whole sentence word-for-word the same as English?

Not quite. A close word-for-word breakdown is:

  • La meva mare = the my mother
  • diu = says
  • que = that
  • la carnisseria = the butcher’s shop
  • que = that/which
  • és prop de = is near
  • l'estació = the station
  • = has
  • carn i ous = meat and eggs

Natural English:

  • My mother says that the butcher’s shop near the station has meat and eggs.

So the meaning matches well, but the grammar is not identical in every detail.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
What's the best way to learn Catalan grammar?
Catalan grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Catalan

Master Catalan — from La meva mare diu que la carnisseria que és prop de l'estació té carn i ous to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.

  • Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • AI tutor to answer your grammar questions