Breakdown of La tour était un immense cylindre avec une sphère en haut.
être
to be
un
a / an (masculine)
une
a / an (feminine)
avec
with
la
her, it (feminine direct object pronoun)
la tour
the tower
en haut
upstairs, at the top
immense
immense
la sphère
the sphere
le cylindre
the cylinder
Questions & Answers about La tour était un immense cylindre avec une sphère en haut.
Wait, I thought "tour" was masculine (le tour). Why is it "la tour" here?
Why is the adjective immense placed before cylindre? Shouldn't most adjectives go after the noun?
While most adjectives follow the noun in French, adjectives related to beauty, age, goodness, and size generally come before it. Since immense describes size, it naturally sits before cylindre. Placing it before the noun also emphasizes the sheer scale of the tower.
Why use the imparfait (était) here instead of the passé composé (a été)?
The imparfait is used here because the sentence is setting a scene and describing a physical state in the past. If you used the passé composé (a été), it would imply the tower was only a cylinder for a specific, completed period of time, which sounds strange for the fixed shape of a building.
Could I say sur le haut instead of en haut for "on top"?
En haut is the most natural, standard adverbial phrase for "up there," "upstairs," or "on top." While you could theoretically say sur le haut de la tour (on the upper part of the tower), en haut stands perfectly on its own to describe the spatial position of the sphere without needing to repeat what it's on top of.
Learn La tour était un immense cylindre avec une sphère en haut and more in French
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free