Question 1

Why do we use the passé composé for il y a eu but the imparfait for nous mangions?

Accepted Answer

This sentence shows a classic interrupted action! Nous mangions (we were eating) sets the ongoing background scene, so it uses the imparfait. Il y a eu (there was) is the sudden, specific event that happened in the middle of our meal, so it uses the passé composé.

Question 2

How do you get il y a eu from il y a?

Accepted Answer

The phrase il y a means "there is" or "there are". To talk about a specific event in the past ("there was"), you put the verb part, which is a (from avoir), into the passé composé. The past participle of avoir is eu, so the phrase becomes il y a eu.

Question 3

Why do we need que after pendant here?

Accepted Answer

Pendant on its own means "during" and must be followed by a noun, like pendant le repas (during the meal). When you want to say "while" and follow it with a subject and a verb (like nous mangions), you have to use the phrase pendant que.

Question 4

I learned that verbs ending in -ger keep the 'e' to keep the soft 'g' sound. Why is it missing in mangions?

Accepted Answer

You are right that manger keeps the 'e' before hard vowels like 'a' or 'o' (for example, nous mangeons in the present tense). But in the imparfait, the nous ending is -ions. Because 'i' is a soft vowel, the 'g' naturally makes the soft "zh" sound without needing an extra 'e'.

Il y a eu une coupure de courant pendant que nous mangions.

Breakdown of Il y a eu une coupure de courant pendant que nous mangions.

Questions & Answers about Il y a eu une coupure de courant pendant que nous mangions.

Learn Il y a eu une coupure de courant pendant que nous mangions and more in French