Breakdown of Bu beceriksiz sekreter, değil rapor yazmak, klavye kullanmayı bile bilmiyor.
bu
this
değil
not
yazmak
to write
bilmek
to know
kullanmak
to use
rapor
report
sekreter
secretary
bile
even
beceriksiz
incompetent
klavye
keyboard
Questions & Answers about Bu beceriksiz sekreter, değil rapor yazmak, klavye kullanmayı bile bilmiyor.
How does the değil ... bile structure work in this sentence?
It translates to "let alone [X], not even [Y]". Değil comes before the extreme or more difficult action (rapor yazmak), and bile comes after the simpler, expected action (klavye kullanmayı). This emphasizes that even the basic requirement isn't met.
Why is it kullanmayı instead of just kullanmak?
The main verb bilmek (to know) requires its specific direct object to take the accusative case. Here, the object is the action of using a keyboard. To add the accusative ending to a verb, we drop the 'k' to use the -mA short infinitive (verbal noun), add the buffer y, and then the accusative -ı, giving us kullanmayı.
Since kullanmayı gets the accusative case, why doesn't rapor yazmak get it too?
In the değil ... bile structure, the action following değil acts as an isolated, hypothetical concept rather than the direct grammatical object of the main verb. Because of this, it stays in its raw dictionary infinitive form (-mAk), while only the actual action tied directly to the main verb (kullanmayı bilmiyor) takes the required case markers.
Could we use da instead of bile in this sentence?
Yes! The particle da can replace bile to mean "even" in this structure. You could say klavye kullanmayı da bilmiyor. Both are very common and natural in daily speech, and they fulfill the exact same role in escalating the exclusivity.
Learn Bu beceriksiz sekreter, değil rapor yazmak, klavye kullanmayı bile bilmiyor and more in Turkish
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free